Update: Huckaby's plea brings sudden end to case
by Justin Lafferty
May 10, 2010 | 10988 views | 67 67 comments | 40 40 recommendations | email to a friend | print
Maria Mestrov lived in the mobile home park for eight years, and was mobbed by reporters on her way out of the park. Glenn Moore/Tracy Press
view slideshow (14 images)
STOCKTON — Melissa Huckaby pleaded guilty this morning to the murder and kidnapping of 8-year-old Tracy girl Sandra Cantu and will be sentenced in June to life in prison without the possibility of parole.

Huckaby’s public defender, Samuel Behar, said he and prosecutor Thomas Testa negotiated for the life sentence without the possibility of parole.

Previously, Testa had been pursuing the death penalty for Huckaby, 29. The other charges against her, including rape with a foreign object and poisoning, were dropped.

Huckaby will be sentenced at 8:30 a.m. on June 14 in Stockton.

The plea brought a surprising, sudden end to the trial phase of a case that gripped the nation shortly after Sandra’s disappearance on March 27, 2009, from her home in the Orchard Estates Mobile Home Park, where both she and Huckaby lived. Ten days later, Cantu’s body was found in a suitcase in a dairy lagoon north of Tracy.

Huckaby was arrested on April 10 on suspicion of kidnapping, raping and killing the girl.

This afternoon, Sandra’s principal at Jacobson Elementary, Cindy Sasser, spoke about how she hoped the ruling would help bring peace to Sandra’s family and friends.

“I think that the community in Tracy has really supported us here, and also the Chavez-Cantu family, they’ve felt the community come together,” Sasser said. “Sandra was definitely a very happy little girl, one that did stand out among the other children.”

Sasser said that the staff at Jacobson has not discussed the matter with students, out of respect of Sandra’s family. She said that some of the staff members are prepared to talk about the case with children, if they ask about it.

In April 2009, a garden and a playground at Jacobson were dedicated in Sandra’s memory. Sasser said that the geraniums and azaleas that are growing in the garden, behind the school’s offices, are blooming in pink and white — Sandra’s favorite colors.

Some people who lived at the mobile home park were surprised to hear the news of Huckaby’s plea.

“The girl was a very nice girl and I don’t know (anybody) that would do that,” said Maria Mestrov, who said she’s lived at Orchard Estates for eight years. “We were very, very shocked.”

While a couple people stopped to talk to about ten television, newspaper and radio reporters waiting outside the entrance of the mobile home park, many others turned onto Clover Road without stopping.

One of those who talked to the media was Susan Alley, 51, who said she’s lived in the mobile home park for three years.

“It helps a bit, but it doesn’t bring her back,” said Alley.

Alley, who said she lived near Sandra’s family, the Chavezes, and two doors down from Huckaby, said that the ordeal has encouraged people living at Orchard Estates to get to know each other a little better. She said she didn’t really know the Chavez family or Huckaby, who she said was “hidden.”

In the courtroom today, San Joaquin County Superior Court Judge Linda Lofthus asked Huckaby if she’s had time to talk with her attorneys and if she really planned to plead guilty, giving up the right to a jury trial, to which she answered yes.

After Lofthus finished most of her questioning of Huckaby, Testa wanted the judge to make sure Huckaby was in the right state of mind to make the plea. He noted that her behavior in prison, such as trying to hurt herself at one point, was odd.

“She appears extremely coherent today, but I just worry down the road,” Testa said, worrying that Huckaby might change her plea.

Lofthus told Testa that “she appears fine to me,” but asked Huckaby anyway if she understood what was going on.

She asked if there has been a change in her medication recently, something Huckaby declined.

“No, I am currently stable on medication, thank you,” Huckaby said.

After the questioning, Lofthus said she accepted Huckaby’s plea. Her attorneys and Testa spoke with members of the Huckaby and Chavez families before coming up with the June 14 date for sentencing.

While Lofthus said she’d allow one camera at the sentencing, she said the gag order, preventing anyone related to the case from speaking to the media, is still in effect. Testa brought up the notion of lifting it and Behar and Huckaby’s attorney, Michael Burt, said they had no objection.

Lofthus said she worried that things were moving too quickly and wanted some time to think about the gag order.

As they left the courtroom, a few members of Sandra's family, the Chavezes were crying. Testa hugged a family member as he walked away. The Chavez family was surrounded by cameras as they walked out of the courthouse and into the parking lot.

"They'll never get over this, but at least they don't have to wait any longer," said Lisa Encarnacion, who at one time was close to the Chavez family.

Contact Tracy Press reporter Justin Lafferty at 830-4221 or jlafferty@tracypress.com.
Comments
(67)
Comments-icon Post a Comment
mochaone
|
May 15, 2010


I don,t think she should be able to have any of the chargers against her dropped she desivers the death pently, she took a life she need to pay for what she has done and putting her in prison for life what a joke, tax payers will be paying for her not right. The Lawyers need to go for the death chair or needles in her arm she is a very mean low life.
RWB
|
May 15, 2010
Coppersmon-I know what the Grand Jury does, I have served on it. AND NO, not this one. We do not indict a ham sandwich!!!!!!! And it IS called a GRAND JURY TRIAL, for your information. Also, under Statute (that means law, since you obviously don't know wha you are talking about) the GRAND JURY TESTIMONY, EVIDENCE, TRANSCIPTS, ETC WILL be released. Grand Jury is NOT what a DA does when they have a weak case, but if is DEFINETLY what they do if they have a DEATH PENALTY CASE THAT WILL COST $ 1,000,000 to try....

Your another lawyer wanna be
Chris87654
|
May 12, 2010
coppersmom - true the grand jury won't convict anyone - it's to see if there's enough evidence to try someone - in this case I'm sure it is overwhelming (MH admitted much - at least you accept she killed Sandra, wrote the letter found by the mailbox, lied about the suitcase, etc and only have trouble accepting the sex aspects). Another reason for the grand jury is it's behind closed doors - the judge didn't want the public to hear of any evidence (the GJ may have been before the gag order).

This was a control issue - Tinfoil said rage, not sex - true, but the rage was probably MHs own (not against Sandra) after holding things in for so long - it just came out on a little girl. Personally I think MH was molested as a child, it was supressed/came out with the fires, self mutilation, mention of suicide at age 12, etc. Not sure what will be revealed if the gag order is lifted, but I highly doubt anything will come out about MHs past - the medical report should be available telling cause of death (remember the judge sealed it because she felt it would cause EVEN MORE public outrage) as well as other evidence.
ConcernedNeighbor
|
May 11, 2010
In some cases, the tell tale signs of troubled youth is their treatment towards animals, if it is noticed by the parents, either they should talk to the child or get the child some help before it manifest into taking a human life.

CN

I agree with Tinfoil since we are seeing increasing number of troubled youth "cutting" themselves.

Stress of times? I don't know.

Tinfoil
|
May 11, 2010
What all this tells me is that problem-solving techniques should be taught in school beginning at an early age. Schooling today has'nt changed much since the Civil War. Society has morphed far beyond the basics. Nobody wants to say it aloud but there's millions of potential Melissas in America today. They need be given tools to survive,prosper and compliment the larger society. Lacking that they only have two ways to express their depression by striking inwards or in Melissa's case,outwards.
5silvas
|
May 11, 2010
MH's plea brings mixed emotions to me. I wanted her to get the death penalty, not escape it. Sandra didn't get a plea bargain for her short life...why should MH? But MH spending the rest of her life in prison might be just as bad as going to h*ll...she has to live with the fact that she killed her daughter's friend, and she ruined so many lives in the process.

I know that I will never be the same..I didn't know the Chavez family or little Sandra, but like so many others, I have taken this whole tragedy to heart. She was everyone's little girl....may Sandra rest in peace and watch over her family, because you know she is saying, "don't worry about me"...
ConcernedNeighbor
|
May 11, 2010
doors17, it sounds so painful to hear an innocent person carrying so much pain around due to family member's mental sickness, it's a "demon" we may never understand for years.

CN
Tinfoil
|
May 11, 2010
Here's my guess at what happened. It was an act of rage not sex. Someone posting here mentioned a screwdriver. Genital mutilation means that Melissa acted out on the victim what she thought of her own genitalia. Takes me back many years when I briefly dated a young woman. I knew she had problems but was shocked one day to find a stack of porno magazines in her apartment. She had used a cigarette to burn the pics of womens' genitalia in the mags. This was her unspoken statement of her own feelings of utter lack of self worth. I believ that Melissa looked in a mirror and saw her present life stinks,that there will be no future for her like other people have. Filled with abysmal depression,resentment and hatred she exploded at her victim.
doors17
|
May 11, 2010
CN, I don't know either family personally but I can tell you both are very friendly, and Sandra's grandfather I've talked to a couple of times, and he comes across as a very, very nice man. I felt sorry for Melissa's grandfather, I would see and talk to him at the mailbox a couple of times of week. Usually our discussion would be about the weather, but you could look into the man's eyes and read his soul that he was in a lot of pain. Melissa's grandparents moved out about the first of the year and their place is still for sale. I feel equally sorry for both families.

When I left for work this morning, the media was gone, and again a big thank you to the Tracy Police Department in keeping them out. That had to be very boring for the officers to sit in their cars, but we really do appreciate them.
ConcernedNeighbor
|
May 11, 2010
If any books or movies come out of this crazy scenario, I would wonder if the society glorifies the morbidity of any crime that occurs by watching the movie or read the book.

I would say Melissa is interesting case study for psychiatrists and psychologists.

I pray that the Chavez and Cantu family finds some comfort in this, but I feel some resentment in her having the years Sandra was robbed of. There sure is something wrong with the picture of the judicial system. Politics?

I hope she will never be considered for a parole!

She really belongs in psychiatric facility since she seems so disassociated from reality of what she had done. Too many issues for her to handle alone. To get to all of them, one would have to open her "Pandora's" box.

I am wondering how the Cantu family is doing.

Good luck.

CN
TracyResident10
|
May 11, 2010
I have mixed feelings on this one. I am glad on one hand that she plead guilty so that there was no chance that she would get off at a trial innocent because of a technicality. On the other hand she is getting off easy. How many times in our system have murderers like this person get paroled after a few short years? Why is it that it seems like the criminals have more rights than us law abiding citizens? You see it all over tracy and other towns where the criminals appear to get away with things while the people who follow the law have to deal with the crime i.e. illigal immigration, gangs and so on. This human trash who admitted she was guilty to this awful crime deserves the same fate she did. But no, she will spend a few years in jail and will be paroled at my expense using my tax doallars to take care of her. We all will meet our maker and will be judged fairly by him and will recieve our just reward, including this human garbage.
doors17
|
May 11, 2010
I'm sure she has mentally issues, but it does seem to me that this is important to many because she's a she. If this were what many of us thought would turn out to be your typical middle age, white male then mentally ill or not a he would be labeled differently.

I don't know the exact number, but it's something like 3 to 5 percent that it turns out to be a women in cases like this, and perhaps that's why many just can't accept which is understandable that she acted alone.
Tinfoil
|
May 11, 2010
Melissa's physical appearance and demeanor alone fairly screams out that this is not the normal child predator case. I do believ she was wham,bam railroaded off to prison purely to satisfy local politics. Melissa belongs in a psych facility under long term care. Has anyone ever sat down with her non-confrontational and asked her why she thinks she did it?
coppersmom
|
May 11, 2010
RWB...you say that everything was proven at a 'GRAND JURY TRIAL'...for your information there is no such thing as a 'GRAND JURY TRIAL". Do you know why? why is it NOT A TRIAL? any idea? what can a defendant not do at a grand jury proceeding?? dO YOU know why no one is ever convicted at such a proceeding? do you know the function? remember this aphorism..'A GRAND JURY WOULD INDICT A HAM SANDWICH..ie..you go to a grant jury for an indictment..not a conviction..when you have a weak case.
coppersmom
|
May 11, 2010
so many of you are sure you know what happened..I'm scratching my head over one theory...ie that prosecutors put out the rape, foreign object rape rumors just so they would have something to negotiate....BECAUSE THEY WANTED TO SPARE HER THE DEATH PENALTY?? why would prosecutors want to spare her the dp?? and yes I understand what plea deals are..I'm a civil, not a criminal lawyer..but that is basic law school 101 stuff. ask yourself this batmen..why won't the judge lift the gag order yet? and another..what really happened? and why couldn't prosecutors prove it?
doors17
|
May 11, 2010
Once the gag order is lifted I'm sure we'll get all the details, and before you know it this story will be a repeated feature on MSNBC's weekend crime stories to the point where soon we'll all be saying, there showing this again ?
cody01
|
May 11, 2010
This entire crime, funeral, all of it, is the worst thing I have ever seen.

I can't comprehend the pain Sandra's family have experienced.

Nobody in their right mind would do something to a child. To anybody.

It makes no sense. None.

Can't comprehend why someone would do that, Got no idea of what to do with them after they did that.

Glad it is not my decision. I can think of only one thing to do with a person like Hukabee.
RWB
|
May 10, 2010
Everyone is so funny. Suddenly everyone is a lawyer, medical examiner and investigator.....Im glad this didn't go to trial, a town full of idiots. It is typical in cases like this for the prosecutor to add charges which reall arent that important (rape/molestation etc). This is so that he can drop them in a plea deal. He doesnt care about those charges, never did. They were a bargaining tool. IT DOES NOT MEAN HE COULD NOT PROVE THEM. Lets not forget, a Grand Jury indicted Huckabee on ALL THE CHARGES. They heard evidence at a Grand Jury Trial. Trust me, when the gag order gets lifted, everyone will hear all the details-what drugs she drugged her with, when she OD, where she died, etc. Look for this to be a movie of the week and an interview with Diane Sawyer or Barbara Walters
Chris87654
|
May 10, 2010
So Tinfoil would have MH stay with her/him? If you feel such compassion, it would be more appropriate for you to stay with her - in jail where killers belong. I don't know legal issues, but it's possible a plea couldn't have been made unless the other charges were dropped. I'm sure family members wouldn't have wanted MH's past brought up. I don't know what will be available to the public when the gag order is lifted, but the ME report will likely come out - it WILL say how Sandra died (I agree it was not "intentional" because MH said it was an "accident" - she was probably drugged [hopefully spared the terror], assaulted, and maybe bled to death or died from OD - but it was still a sick monster who did the intentional act that resulted in death).
whoareyoukidding
|
May 10, 2010
coppersmom - Hence the word plea bargain. A plea bargain is done to save $$, to avoid more trauma to the victims and to allow the defendant to obtain a "benefit". There is no reason to believe that she did not commit every crime that was charged. It was stated several times that if the truth about what she did was revealed the family and citizens of Tracy would have been traumatized again. I don’t understand why you and Tinfoil are taking this monsters side.


We encourage readers to share online comments in this forum, but please keep them respectful and constructive. This is not a space for personal attacks, libelous statements, profanity or racist slurs. Comments that stray from the topic of the story or are found to contain abusive language are subject to removal at the Press’ discretion, and the writer responsible will be subject to being blocked from making further comments and have their past comments deleted. Readers may report inappropriate comments by e-mailing the editor at tpnews@tracypress.com.