Lack of garbage fees begins to pile up
by Justin Lafferty/ TP staff
Jan 09, 2010 | 2701 views | 35 35 comments | 14 14 recommendations | email to a friend | print
Piles of garbage are guided toward the conveyor belt at Tracy Delta Disposal on MacArthur Drive. Garbage rates for Tracy residents may soon increase, as the city’s waste disposal department is dealing with a deficit.   Glenn Moore/Tracy Press
view slideshow (3 images)
The lack of construction and the abundance of foreclosed homes in Tracy have forced the city’s public works department to look into raising garbage collection rates to close a growing deficit.

Zane Johnston, Tracy’s finance director, said the waste department’s $17 million budget operated at a roughly $1.1 million loss in the 2008-09 fiscal year and has been in the red three of the past four fiscal years. He added that there’s about $1.5 million left in the bank, and another rough year could be dangerous.

“If we experience another loss the magnitude of this year’s loss, then we would virtually wipe out all the cash in the fund,” Johnston said. “You can’t sustain operating losses here, because you have nowhere else to go with your money.”

Kevin Tobeck, the public works director, said the problem his department faces is threefold. Few houses have been built in the past few years, so there has been no construction debris to discard. Tracy is also home to a swarm of empty, foreclosed houses, where no garbage is collected so no bills are sent out, he said.

“We went from lots of building to virtually none,” he said.

Tobeck added that the value of recyclables has gone down, too.

Tobeck said he and Johnston are in the early stages of looking into higher garbage rates, and no decision is expected to go before the City Council until the spring. He said he didn’t know yet how much rates would be boosted.

Johnston said the garbage fund works much like a checking account — getting revenue solely from recyclables and from residents and businesses that pay their monthly bills (an average of $29.95 for houses), and then spending that money to collect and dispose of the city’s trash. Tobeck said rates have not gone up since July 2007.

Out of that money the department has available, Johnston said, it doesn’t pay employees, so there’s no one they can lay off, furlough or cut pay to. Instead, the work is contracted out to Tracy Delta Disposal for collection and Tracy Materials and Recovery Inc. for disposal, Johnston said.

“It’s those things you don’t control that make it extremely difficult,” Johnston said.

In the 2007-08 fiscal year, the waste account was in the black, because more people paid their bills, Johnston said. Before that, though, the department had losses of more than $1 million in the two prior fiscal years.

Tobeck said it will take public works a couple of months of analysis, as well as discussion with Johnston and a consultant, before any action is taken. He said raising rates is an idea he and Johnston have tossed around the past few months.

“Nothing’s been decided, but we’re going to take a closer look,” Tobeck said.
Comments
(35)
Comments-icon Post a Comment
mnwild
|
January 10, 2010
CN,

Yard waste (brown toter) collected IS composted at the Material Recovery Facility (MRF) and then sold back to individuals and businesses. My landscaper used it when he replaced our lawn a few years ago.

San Joaquin County Waste Management offers information about composting and in the past has given "lessons" on how to set up a compost bin at home. There are also schools with class gardens that set up compost bins using discarded food from the lunch room. It's a great lesson for the kids (they especially like working with the red worms), but takes dedication on the part of teachers to make it happen.

Recovery of organic materials (like food waste) from the garbage (green toters) would be costly. As it is now, I often see blue and brown toters contaminated with garbage waiting to be collected curbside as I drive by. These toters end up being sorted as garbage. The more CORRECT recycling done curbside, the lower the overall cost to process.

Unfortunately, recycling is a "learned skill" and tho our generation is getting better at it, it's our kids who will make it a part of how they live because they will have no choice.

ConcernedNeighbor
|
January 10, 2010
What about "composing", couldn't the landfill turn the "organic garbage" into composing materials... without inorganic materials? Or has that been done in Tracy? Think of the compost heap you could sell to the farmers/gardeners of Tracy to defray the cost?

Just curious.

Go Green! Use canvas bags when shopping, at least I do, easy to carry on my bike if I choose not to drive.

Good luck.

CN

victor_jm
|
January 10, 2010
Sorry, that was "garbage."
victor_jm
|
January 10, 2010
I separate my household waste. I place my green waste-container on the curbside every three weeks. Yes, I am subsidizing the waste management of entropically-irresponsible consumers.

I contend garage pick-up for residents ought to be every two weeks, but those who generate a lot of trash will contend they are unable to be resourceful and diligent.

Waste-generation is one of many ways we employ people because we are mindfully wasteful.

Green_Acres
|
January 09, 2010
stork,

You mean a stipend? And why would they declare bankruptcy? Just keep the recycling bins and cancel the contract on the green trash bins. People can pay Materials and Recovery Inc directly for their trash.

Believe you me people would recycle a WHOLE lot more.
markswatching
|
January 09, 2010
MNwild,

Thanks for the clear and consise explanation. It would really help if the TP could get good sorces to add to the articles that we read and comment on daily.

Thanks again I feel smarter than I was before your comments.
storkfmny
|
January 09, 2010
Maybe the city should consider bankruptcy and renegotiate all contracts, or would they be afraid that they would have to renegotiate salaries and benefits of the city council themselves.
Green_Acres
|
January 09, 2010
I wonder why the tracy press didn't tell customers the advantage of packing the blue bin with recyclables. Instead of using the trash bin as a single stream recycling can.

After reading the "editorial" on page 17 of today's Tracy Press and wondered if they had been instructed by an investor or other stake holder?
mnwild
|
January 09, 2010
I worked for another city for 2 years in the solid waste division. Hope this helps some of you understand "garbage" a little better.

- Most garbage collection contracts are multi-year. (The city I worked for negotiated a 10 year contract in 2004.) I'd bet the one between the City and Tracy Disposal is the same. That means prices were negotiated when the economy was up, and now that it isn't, Tracy and other cities (including the one I worked for) are finding it necessary to increase rates.

- It would be nice to renegotiate the contract, but there has to be language that allows this, or it isn't gonna happen. Also, there aren't very many companies in the "garbage biz". The start-up costs are high (new toters, trucks, resources, etc.) and it can be a logistical nightmare changing garbage companies. Ultimately the customers suffer most from this type of transition (been there, done that).

- Normally the return on recyclables offsets expenses, but as was stated, the bottom has fallen out of that market. Cardboard used to be shipped overseas to China to use for the products they manufacture. The US and other countries aren't buying due to poor economic conditions, so there's no need for China to buy our cardboard to use as packaging. It's a vicious cycle that results in pallets of used cardboard sitting on docks hoping for someone to buy them.

- Even aluminum and plastics are not paying as much as in the past. In addition, there are more individuals recycling than before to help defray personal expenses, so the City isn't getting that return.

- The piles of trash seen in the pictures will be sorted before being sent into the landfill. You'd be amazed at what finally ends up in a landfill. It is a very small portion of what it collected.

-When customers recycle, it saves $$$$ because the recycled materials are already pulled out of the waste stream. All garbage collected is sent through a conveyer system to pull metals, paper, usable cardboard, plastics, etc. out using magnets, automated sorters and manpower. Using this system costs extra $$$$$, which is why it's better for customers to sort the recyclables in the beginning.

ConcernedParents
|
January 09, 2010
Good points Green_Acres.

Some County residents may not know (in the county they do not offer recycling yet.... they should but don't) that Delta Disposal offers large, blue recycling bags at no expense, for all recyclables and they are picked up along with your regular trash, weekly.

ConcernedParents
|
January 09, 2010
"too" that is
Green_Acres
|
January 09, 2010
Lot of recyclables in there. People could go a long way toward keeping their bills down if everyone would recycle. Otherwise it only fills up landfills.

I can't help but wonder how many Tracy Press' newspapers are filling up landfills? I looked inside for the recycling symbol and couldn't find it anywhere.

ConcernedParents
|
January 09, 2010
We agree to Amy trash begets trash!
ConcernedParents
|
January 09, 2010
Wow, look at all of the cardboard and other recyclable materials being dumped by the garbage truck! People, recycle! Then there won't be as much garbage to be hauled away. Who knows.... maybe you can even get a smaller can and save money that way?
markswatching
|
January 09, 2010
CN I totally agree.
ConcernedNeighbor
|
January 09, 2010
Why not round up truant kids and have them serve community time by recycling, perhaps they will see it is not the future they want... trash begets trash.....

Sorry, dark side of Amy speaking.

CN
markswatching
|
January 09, 2010
Why not go back out for bid and see if they can find someone to do the job for less?
Green_Acres
|
January 09, 2010
adios, good luck with your agenda. There's no money to buy you a "slushie".

Delta Disposal already reduced to one driver with automated can collector. Ask them if they can pass on the savings.

People voted for a teleprompter. What else did you expect.
tracy-ed
|
January 09, 2010
“Nothing’s been decided, but we’regoing to take a closer look”

is official Tracy muni-speak for:

"we know what we're going to do and the next you'll hear about it is after we've already done it".

Pardon my cynicism, just seems to be a pattern.
ConcernedNeighbor
|
January 09, 2010
Wished the people would wear eye goggles and face mask when working with the waste, those wastes are not sanitary!!

Take care of your health, you could get them at the dollar store? (If the sanitation department would not provide the face guard)??

CN


We encourage readers to share online comments in this forum, but please keep them respectful and constructive. This is not a space for personal attacks, libelous statements, profanity or racist slurs. Comments that stray from the topic of the story or are found to contain abusive language are subject to removal at the Press’ discretion, and the writer responsible will be subject to being blocked from making further comments and have their past comments deleted. Readers may report inappropriate comments by e-mailing the editor at tpnews@tracypress.com.