Update: Fatal accident at Tracy intersection
by TP staff
Sep 29, 2009 | 6314 views | 68 68 comments | 30 30 recommendations | email to a friend | print
A car crash in Tracy sent four people to the hospital Saturday, one of whom was pronounced dead later that day.

Police showed up to the two-car crash at West Valpico Road and Sycamore Parkway at about 3:40 p.m. Saturday, finding one car on the center median and the other in the middle of the intersection, according to Tracy police Sgt. Luis Mejia. Tracy police closed the intersection for a few hours for investigation and cleanup.

Tracy police spokesman Sgt. Tony Sheneman said Tuesday that an investigation into the cause of the crash is ongoing and that he had no further details.

Photos show that a silver Honda collided with a dark blue Mercedes-Benz SUV. The driver’s side of the Honda was smashed in. A relative identified the man who died in the crash as Ricardo Navia, a 45-year-old from Modesto who was in town to visit another family member.

Sheneman said an autopsy report is being compiled.

Police records say the driver of the Mercedes walked away before officers arrived, but that might be a miscommunication, according to the sister of one of the SUV’s passengers. She said a witness misidentified her brother — who panicked and left the vehicle — as the driver. The sister, who asked not to be identified, said her brother is only 15 and was a passenger.

The driver, she said, was her brother’s 16-year-old best friend, whom she also refused to identify by name.

Both were wearing white T-shirts, the relative said, but her brother’s shirt had paintball stains on the back. There were paintballs in the back of the SUV, she said, and they exploded upon impact.

Emergency responders ordered a helicopter to take one person to Doctors Hospital in Modesto and sent Tracy police Chaplain Don Higgins to the hospital shortly after the crash, after reports arrived that Navia was dying, according to the dispatch log.

Comments
(68)
Comments-icon Post a Comment
whitegirldd
|
October 13, 2009
to whom it may concern,

I am a concerned citizen who was wondering if anyone had any new information on this situation?

All I keep seeing is the same postings, so if anyone has anything new 2 add please do a.s.a.p!
jayla603
|
October 06, 2009
excuse me, but the person who was killed here was a father, brother, son and my cousin. 15 years or not if he was so intellegent he would not have been behind the wheel of a vehicle driving wrecklessly. NOBODY, NOBODY should have left the scene i don't care how scared you were, you just committed a crime and if it was my brother i WOULD not take the blame for taking someone's life. please show some respect and send prayers to my family and not make excuses for the so called child. now his children's mother is left alone to raise and explain to her babies why their dad won't be around to see them grow up pass 15.
sleepy2
|
October 05, 2009
The Expensive SUV has a "black box"...everything the driver did is recorded.

by the way:

Calif teen gets 15 years in death of passenger

SANTA ANA, Calif. (AP) -- A judge sentenced an unlicensed teenage driver to 15 years to life in the death of a classmate after he drank several shots of rum and crashed his mother's car.

Milad Moulayi, 18, of Tustin was sentenced Friday to the maximum term for second-degree murder for the 2008 single-car crash that killed 16-year-old Mackenzie Frazee after a party.

Orange County Superior Court Judge Carla Singer told the Moulayi that he had committed a "brutal and violent crime," and had been warned about driving without a license before.

Moulayi apologized and asked Frazee's family for forgiveness before he was sentenced.

Witnesses said at trial that the teenager was stumbling drunk when he insisted on driving Frazee home.
209rez
|
October 05, 2009
mexicanmex - you're mom was the driver of the Honda that was struck?
mexicanmex
|
October 05, 2009
all i can say is that from what i heard from my mom the driver, is that the suv ran the stop sigh after she made a stop, come on now people shes 55 years old she obeys the law in every aspect never had a ticket what so ever so you make the call.
sadforever
|
October 04, 2009
I AM SO SORRY FOR THE HONDA'S LOSS.

YOU B**** ITZTHEANSWER AND UNKOWON209, BETTER WATCH FOR YOUR WORTLESS WORDS, I JUST TELL YOY THIS MUCH "WHAT GOES AROUND, COMES AROUND" GOD IS THERE FOR EVERYONE. JUST TAKE THIS AS A WAKE UP CALL FROM GOD AND PRAY FOR YOUR UPCOMING FUTUER.
shelly13
|
October 04, 2009
My kids have not heard any talk around town as to who these kids are. I know they cannot release the names, but can they or anyone say what high school they attend?
unknown456
|
October 04, 2009
okay I just want to clarify a few things...

1st. There was no alcohol involved so please stop making false statements.

2nd. They did not have any knives to begin with so I don't know where the heck you are coming up with this info about knives being thrown in the bushes.

3rd. You are wrong about the driver not going to jail. Yea unfortunately he won't get life I'm prison but I know for a fact he will serve time.

People please don't believe what these low lives are saying. It will be a while before Tracy PD releases the police report so these people know absolutely nothing about the case or the evidence obtained. Now they are just making their own little stories up for the attention they never had as a child.

unknown209
|
October 03, 2009
once again .. THE CAR (mercedes) was NOT STOLEN.
shelly13
|
October 03, 2009
Anyone know whether all parties were wearing seatbelts?
ConcernedNeighbor
|
October 03, 2009
Interesting, did they take blood alcohol levels of the boys who walked away?

The sister at the scene?

Who are they trying to protect and why? Seemed to have such vested interests in what they do?

Mercedes, whose car is that???

Remember, the family whose husband/father/son/brother/uncle/cousin.....was taken in the accident, the help they need is posted in the other article.

Will the sister help these family, too?

What if it were to happen to her in the future?

How would she want to be helped?

So sad, sad situation, parents can't be very happy with their sons?

Just waiting to see what the investigators say of their findings...

CN
shelly13
|
October 03, 2009
You know if it comes out that the Honda was at fault and the driver had a high alcohol level, then I may have given my apology to the SUV kids and just stressed to them the importance of the one staying at the scene. After all we were only going on the info given to us by the paper.

However, No apologies for their friends who have represented themselves and other kids of their age very poorly. There are many good kids out there who you have now given a bad name. Shame on you!

Either way my condolences to the family who lost a loved one. It is a tragedy in any way, shape or form.
209rez
|
October 03, 2009
I find it interesting that neither article mentioned the involvement of alcohol. The articles certainly leave much out.

We'd probably take iTzTheAnswer and the information being provided more seriously if they weren't on here acting like an uneducated retard, trying to act like a thug. Do us a favor and stop trying to represent your friends. You're just making them look bad with your cussing and threats. No one is threatened by you. If anything, you are just making us lose what little sympathy we already have for them.

If you can provide objective facts in a calm manner then we can all get somewhere. Until then just STFU mmmkay?! So run along little troll...come back when you've calmed down.

unknown209 - can you corroborate the alcohol statement?
shelly13
|
October 03, 2009
WOW you really show your age and lack of intelligence here. There are different types of accidents child. Do your parents know you are here writing all this? Very sad, just wait until you grow up. My children are around the same age and they certainly do not talk as poorly and with the lack of empathy as you have for the victims in the Honda. Without knowing it YOU are perpetuating the anger some may have for your friends because you "dumsh*ts" are acting like unsympathetic spoiled brats. You may not be that way in person, but you represent you and your friends very poorly here.
shelly13
|
October 02, 2009
offtoworkigo could have a point. I just think if that was the scenario the kids defending the SUV driver could and should have told us that from the beginning (in a calm mature manner). Then none of this banter would even be an issue.
shelly13
|
October 02, 2009
There are in fact laws and penalties for unintended acts. Be clear on that. That is legally, remember there is also a civil aspect where the family can sue the kids parents or guardians and that can happen with less evidence than is needed for a legal court of law. The best scenario for your brother and friends is that they find the Honda completely at fault, otherwise you guys may be in for a rough road.

Now when compiling evidence they will also look at the kids involved...did they have priors? Were they good students etc. Then they will make decisions on how they want to proceed with the case. Each case is different and if the kids are found to be at fault, it would make a difference on why they were at fault and what type of kids they are. There maybe no great penalty or jail if let's say he was distracted and rolled through sign versus racing, for example.

Or they may find that they went and the Honda was at fault. Who knows, I just know that I was t-boned from a car going about 35 mph and the damage to our vehicle was similar. So that is what I have personally to compare it too.

My kids are the same age and I worry about them and their friends all the time. I hope if nothing else this is a topic that encourages parent to talk and stress to their kids the importance of safe driving and what they should do and not do if in a tragic situation such as this.
unknown209
|
October 02, 2009
did i say u said that EXACT phase??

NO.

but ur basically implying it in what ur saying
unknown209
|
October 02, 2009
JUSTICE FOR AN UNINTENDED ACT?

YA .. SOME LAW AND SOME JUSTICE WE HAVE IN THIS COUNTRY?
123modesto
|
October 02, 2009
i never said rot in jail. that's just you putting words in other peoples mouths.

the law is the law and justice is always served.
offtoworkigo
|
October 02, 2009
Man there is a lot of stuff being thrown around.

Ever see a car that hit a tree or pole as it was sliding sideways. Looks just like a t-bone.

What if the suv was going slow and pulled away from the stop sign, Honda blows the sign, overreacts, slides sideways and creats a classic t-bone into the suv.

I'm only throwing this out there because there are a multitude of ways this could have happened. We will know soon enough after the investigation has been completed.

Until then, the mud slingin is just that. Grow up.


We encourage readers to share online comments in this forum, but please keep them respectful and constructive. This is not a space for personal attacks, libelous statements, profanity or racist slurs. Comments that stray from the topic of the story or are found to contain abusive language are subject to removal at the Press’ discretion, and the writer responsible will be subject to being blocked from making further comments and have their past comments deleted. Readers may report inappropriate comments by e-mailing the editor at tpnews@tracypress.com.