Your Voice: No more city extortion
by Skip Thompson, Tracy
Aug 14, 2009 | 949 views | 18 18 comments | 8 8 recommendations | email to a friend | print
EDITOR,

I am a local contractor in Tracy. I’ve lived in Tracy most of my 47 years. I’ve had my state contractor’s license since 1992 and my city business license (a local tax) since the West Valley Mall was built.

After living at the same residence for more than 12 years, I moved in January about a quarter-mile from my old place. So when my city business license came up for renewal, the city wanted an extra $5 for a change of address and an extra $10 for a new home business application.

Nobody else wanted any money from me to change my address — not the Internal Revenue Service, not the state Franchise Tax Board, not the state Contractors Board, not my insurance companies, not my bank, not my phone company, not my cable, not my utility company. Only the city.

So I sent back my business license renewal with a note to change my address. A couple of days later, I got a call from the city about the change of address and the $5, so I filled out the form and went down to City Hall with 500 pennies. They refused my money.

Not only did they refuse my $5, they also gave me a new form for a “home business application” for the $10 more.

I refused to pay and left the application on the desk. So I was told that I was going to be reported to the development department — whatever that is.

I know people will scoff at me for making a big deal out of $15, but I am sick and tired of being extorted by the government. We business owners and citizens are being “15-dollared to death,” and I am not paying any more without a fight.

I just hope the city doesn’t send the fire department to collect the $15, because that might cost me an extra $300 paramedic fee.

Comments
(18)
Comments-icon Post a Comment
SJSharksFan
|
August 18, 2009
Skip - a penny saved is a penny earned. Nothing wrong with challenging the status quo. With so many Tracy small businesses closing in this economy, the city and its "development" department sure must be on another plant. If they're not willing to cut you a break as a 47-yr resident and small business owner, tell them you'll move your business tax dollars to another city. Suggestion - ask to talk to the "boss", not the robots at the teller window.
RedHotChilliPeppers
|
August 17, 2009
They ouhta charged you the fifteen for the change of address plus a fee for taking those rolls of pennies. Or you coulda taken the pennies to the machine at SaveMart but they woulda dinged ya for another fee too. Anyway coulda woulda shoulda. Ya gotta ask yourself if you wanna do business or not. Then brush yourself off an do it. Moping around in this economy just don't make sense. Especially when Tracy is one of the only cities keepin contractors like yourself puttin food on the table. Lotta other folks can't say that.

And any ol' city will charge you at least fifteen bucks for a one day permit ya peddal your wares. Ya got the whole year.
Ornley_Gumfudgen
|
August 17, 2009
Well if ya brought me 1,500 pennies ta pay yer bill I'd be givin it back ta ya as well.

Check it out, ya can't pay yer bills like that. Anythin over 50 cents has to be rolled with yer name an address on it ta make sure ya ain't cheatin.

Brush yerself up on these things before ya start yammerin on about havin ta pay $15 cause ya moved. Be thankful ya have a business ta move in th first place.

And if a one time $15 is all it costs ya an that straps yer business then I'd recommend findin yerself some other work cause this business is goin bust.
KDK
|
August 17, 2009
Just pay the GD fees.

It takes a live person to enter in the changes, process your paperwork, and mail the new stuff out to your new address. Time is money.

The IRS doesn't charge fees, no. But doesn't everyone agree that they get enough money out of us, already?
What_OpenTheGitmoPrisonDoors
|
August 17, 2009
Getting Sadam to stop gassing the Kurds was worth every penny. For days on end nobody thought we would get a gas out of driving our tanks into Firdos Square and watching the emancipated engaged in toppling the statue of tyranny. By the time we got to Woodstock any weapons had been long removed across the borders. Let Laden grow old there. Who cares?

In the seventies we had peanuts and we loved it. Remember the Church Witchhunt of the 70's? I guess that's the price you pay for doing the business. The CIA lied and Cheney had it out for her, who cares. It's demoralizing and panzy-izing of America that we NOW face. Senior citicens in wheel-chairs are being accused of 'Swastika-Carrying thugs'.

Where are the real terrorists in America?

The prisoners are escaping.

RedHotChilliPeppers
|
August 16, 2009
For fifteen hundred pennies you can purchase enough gas for a trip to the library and get a book on gardening and then fill your lawnmower and call it a day. Your choice, unlike public option and single payer. Otherwise, pick up a good book on How To Start A Home Based Business For Dummies. If were worried about fifteen hundred pennies I'll offer you those pennies for a hundred percent stake in your business and you never call me again. I can smell a winner a mile away. That's swimming with the sharks amigo. Just don't end up on the right hand side of Ezekial Emmanuel's chart (or the wrong side as the case may be)
ChineseThoughtReform
|
August 16, 2009
We just spent 22 trillion dollars this year. 23 trillion dollars if the POTUS let's Granma Nanci care loose.
anonymous
|
August 16, 2009
"Obviously you are a follower and not a leader. People like you will continue to let others run roughshod over you."

seriously its 15 bucks. Get over it. Your goverenment just spent trillions of your and our dollars looking for weapons of mass destruction that dont exist yet you are concerned about the one time 15 dollar charge for a business licence change of address.

I am not a follower, I just know when to fight and when to enjoy a couple of lattes.

I will have a grande triple with two splendas.

Thank you

briandub

ChineseThoughtReform
|
August 16, 2009
Who cares? We cares.

In some 3rd world countries you can get away with pirating videos.

Any home based business can pay 15 hundred yen to the local chief and be done with it.

Here in America it costs someone money to process paperwork.

Someone is getting paid more than thirty dollars an hour. You're getting a bargain.

In any country.

http://www.ci.lathrop.ca.us/business/pdf/BusinessLicenseApplication_000.pdf
offtoworkigo
|
August 16, 2009
anonymous @ 6:18 PM

Obviously you are a follower and not a leader. People like you will continue to let others run roughshod over you.

I'd almost lay a 100 bucks on the fact that you work for the city and every penny they can steal from our pockets helps ensure your job.

Learn to stand up for what is right because next time it may (and will) be something bigger.

Next time be a good little follower and leave your opinions in your head.

P.S. Are you one of these people I see sitting in the line at Starbucks every day? You do know that 5 bucks a pop can add up to serious coin at the end of the year. Glad to hear you're doing so well.
anonymous
|
August 16, 2009
Its 15 bucks. Again, its 15 bucks. Or three grande mochas, two round table lunch buffets,one bottle of wine or 15 ipod song downloads.

Send in the check and move on. Life is too short for making a stand against the city for the equivelent of three grande mochas.
MedicAndExDemocrat
|
August 16, 2009
OMGoodyness!

Folks, first, the city doesn't send the FIRE DEPARTMENT. They contract that out to the AMR to handle 911 calls and dispatch the calls to the FIRE DEPARTMENT. Additionally, the city doesn't send the PARAMEDIC. Again, that is the AMR and is County run. The PARAMEDIC won't cost you a dime. It is covered by insurance. Whether you purchase private or public option. Good grief! Everybody is just complaining and complaining about health care this and co-payment that. Point is people dont know what they are even saying. Let's get our facts straight. OK? The cost of health care doubled in the last nine years.

To put it into focus. Who will pay for the one trillion dollars plus the seven hundred and eight seven billion dollars we already spent on cobra? The author of this letter shows us all a good reason why NancyCare is going to fail. And most people are going to let the democrats steam roll us because we think the city sends the PARAMEDIC. No wonder we got stuck with the worst Congress in history. It's really the voters fault.

And, given that fact, I hate to say it but fifteen dollars is really nothing. The stupid voters obviously deserve it. We are only left to wonder if voters out there even have an inkling - who is going to pay for NANCY'S BIG PARAMEDIC PICTURE?

Fact. The cost of NancyCare is going to get spread out to the state and local levels because the feds have figured out how not to raise your taxes. The solution. Since Medicare is State. Then let the State, County, City, and local governments raise your taxes. That's how the Democrats can say THEY won't raise YOUR taxes. It has to come from somewhere.

If you can't see it and vote accordingly. You deserve what you get.
Health_Care_Lies_exposed
|
August 15, 2009
Ha! Ok, you guys are cute.

Apparently some city employee has been surfing the City's Internet and using "FaceBook" on our taxpayer dime.

http://www.facebook.com/cityoftracy

Simply scandalous (kidding of course)

LOL!
anonymous
|
August 15, 2009
They have to revenue generate at all times. Someone needs to pay for the civic employees on facebook, twitter and online surfing all day!
ebflo
|
August 15, 2009
Probably has to do with the City's financial guy. You should call the City Manager and ask why they want this additional charge when no one else does.
offtoworkigo
|
August 15, 2009
I agree, the city is constantly looking for ways to nickle and dime us to death.
anonymous
|
August 15, 2009
IndianaJones
|
August 15, 2009
Did you do a comparison and see if you could try Manteca or Lathrop? I just thought they are laying off police there in Lathrop and Manteca financed themselves overh their heads in debt?

(kinda like the health care package will do to US)

Anyway, for the price of a lunch ticket here in Tracy, CA you get a much more stable economic eco-system.

And it still costs less than Livermore and Pleasanton.

But hey, I get it, fifteen bucks is fifteen bucks.


We encourage readers to share online comments in this forum, but please keep them respectful and constructive. This is not a space for personal attacks, libelous statements, profanity or racist slurs. Comments that stray from the topic of the story or are found to contain abusive language are subject to removal at the Press’ discretion, and the writer responsible will be subject to being blocked from making further comments and have their past comments deleted. Readers may report inappropriate comments by e-mailing the editor at tpnews@tracypress.com.