Our Voice: Graffiti art in Tracy? We’re not that lucky
by The Editorial Board
Aug 07, 2009 | 2020 views | 9 9 comments | 33 33 recommendations | email to a friend | print
This might come as a surprise to those whose property has been defaced, but it’s no shock to us that alleged taggers recently arrested by the Tracy police probably prefer the term “artist” to “vandal.”

It’s not as absurd as it seems. Graffiti can indeed be art.

Many cities — Los Angeles is a prime example — boast spray-painted murals arguably as beautiful as anything hanging in a modern art museum. They liven up otherwise drab concrete and add character to neighborhoods in dire need of it.

It makes us wonder if that approach would help alleviate our vandalism problem in Tracy. The number of graffiti reports fielded by police so far in 2009 has more than doubled in comparison to the same time frame a year ago, and police and vigilant residents can only do so much.

Wouldn’t it be nice if these taggers, instead of making a name for themselves as spray-painting hacks on the streets, made a name for themselves as real, respected artists?

Imagine the city agreeing to turn over stretches of cinderblock sound walls to talented youngsters, or chunks of vibrantly painted concrete sitting as part of the Grand Theatre Center for the Arts’ next gallery exhibit.

Unfortunately, that’s not the kind of constructive bent most of these taggers are wont to take. Because that would largely defeat the purpose of what they’re doing — establishing a niche within a distinct subculture while thumbing their noses at authority.

While one or two might jump at such a chance, a constructive outlet such as a show at the Grand Theatre would not satisfy these other desires. And let’s face it, taking initiative to talk to people at City Hall or the Grand is not exactly the modus operandi of tagging crews.

Until the day comes when Tracy’s illegitimate spray-painters choose a canvas that’s not the property of someone else, what they’re doing is vandalism. And woe to those who can’t make that painfully obvious distinction.

So some advice to our friends wielding the aerosol cans: If you want to be hunted down by police, keep on doing what you’re doing. If you want to be considered an artist, act like one.
Comments
(9)
Comments-icon Post a Comment
Wobbley
|
June 24, 2011
I agree, it's art, as long as it's on your legal property not someone elses.

TAGGERS SUCK!
tracyman
|
August 08, 2009
I 100% agree with shelly13. How ever the city has a set amount of money for clean up of vandalism, we have already heard that the money is runing out to clean all this up. I have a hard time believing that if there was not graffiti or vandalism then there would be a plentifull more activities for teenagers to particpate in. And no most of these "taggers" dont understand the cities financial policies or even fully comprehend the outcome of effects there art has on the city. Thats not my point, what I am tring to convey hear is that it doesnt really matter on the life style, behavior, or choices one makes in regards to wither or not they create art. Art is a creative process that comes from with in some ones being, some artist have to express themselves no matter what. I am in no way saying that vandalising some ones property is ok, I am just saying that 75% of the taggers produce real art, even if the store owner doesnt like it on his wall. And yes most of these kids do it because there is nothing for them to do in Tracy, they would probably do it even if we had a better rec center, or better aquatic center. I see your point though shelly.
SJSharksFan
|
August 08, 2009
Art is in the eye of the beholder. Once it infringes on others - placed where it is NOT appreciated or permitted by law, it ceases to be Art and is defacement of private or public property.
ConcernedNeighbor
|
August 08, 2009
Excuse me, tracyman, where did I say graffiti artists in THIS article?

I said "Taggers," and "Defacers" marring up properties with ugly works. They don't even deserve to be called Graffiti Artists!!!

Shelly13 has the right suggestions.

No to defacements of any properties!

PLUS, I do paint in various mediums as side hobby... and I do not appreciate those punks(taggers and defacers) giving true Graffiti Artists a bad name.
shelly13
|
August 08, 2009
Also I have made the suggestion before for the true artists out there...get something going like they have in other cities. Non-profit groups that do positive things with the artists in showcasing their art and helping kids in their community. I even put up some website of these other groups. Obvioulsy they don't care or are too lazy to promote their cause, which could turn out to be a very nice project for them and our city. So to me, unless they grow up and are willing to do a little leg work to make things right and be able to continue their art, they are no more than criminal punks for now.
shelly13
|
August 08, 2009
I have said below that it is both..in some cases. Some of it is strictly garbage and tagging, where some is very good graffiti or street art. The problem is in fact the defacement and vandalism of private and public property that costs the city, taxpayers and private home and landowners extra money to clean up. Now, I know right now there is no way I could afford to clean up the hoodlums mess since I am now out of a job. I would be soooo pissed of they did that to me!

Many of them have complained that they have nothing to do here in Tracy, yet what they are doing costs the city money and in turn the reult means there is less money for programs for the kids. Less money for the rec department, less money for the aquatics center, less money for the sports park and Grand Theater. Don't they understand that, tracyman!?
tracyman
|
August 08, 2009
Apparently ConcernedNeighbor is not an artist and has no idea what its like to be an artist. And probably has no idea what graffiti art is all about, just another typical confromed Tracy resident like all the rest. "Black art" what is supposed to be ment by that??? Ohh and why is there all this criteia that an artist must practice under?. Who says you need light to do art? Arnt there blind artists? I undertand being upset at defacing property but it is what it is, It may be vandalism but its also art !!! Why are there so many people who cant understand this????
ConcernedNeighbor
|
August 08, 2009
An artist needs lots of light to work with, so they could see the true colors and medium they work with. An artist works with their OWN canvas, property. An artist paints the side of a building on commission/contract. An artist seeks permission to do their display of work with proper authorities. They are proud to be ACKNOWDLEDGED as the ones who created art of various mediums.

TAGGERS, or DEFACERS work in the DARK. They do not want to be SEEN. They do not want to be acknowledged as ones who have done it. They deface properties that is not their own. They did not seek permission. They were flaunting the law by molesting the city of Tracy with their black arts. Spray paint is the only medium they use!????

BE PROUD OF YOUR CITY!

I agree with TP!
tracyman
|
August 08, 2009
How does the way you act determine if your an artist or not. Its not the behavior or the way you act in society that makes you an artist, it is the creative process that flows through an artist and that creative product developed from that process that makes some one an artist. This may however coincide with vandalism which in turn creates problems for people. But it does not mean that just because its vandalism that its not art, its just both and thats one of the main concept in graffiti, the rush of what your doing is illegal but also creative. If all you people dont like the graffit around town I suggest that the Tracy Press stop printing grffiti articles every week and giving these "artist" what they want, more publicity and attention, thats just what they want. Way to play right into the their game Tracy press.


We encourage readers to share online comments in this forum, but please keep them respectful and constructive. This is not a space for personal attacks, libelous statements, profanity or racist slurs. Comments that stray from the topic of the story or are found to contain abusive language are subject to removal at the Press’ discretion, and the writer responsible will be subject to being blocked from making further comments and have their past comments deleted. Readers may report inappropriate comments by e-mailing the editor at tpnews@tracypress.com.