Town Crier: Celebrate freedom from oppression
by Samina Masood
Jul 07, 2009 | 1771 views | 19 19 comments | 25 25 recommendations | email to a friend | print
My Utopia is a country without religion.

You drive down the landscape of my dreamland without coming across a single church, mosque, synagogue or temple. There is complete freedom from institutions that divide people based on their religious beliefs. Monks, nuns, priests, mullahs — there are none in my dreamland. People congregate free of the labels Muslim, Jew or Christian. There is no box on your passport that specifies religion.

In my Utopia, the overriding belief is unconditional love for one another. Hate and bigotry are considered archaic animal instincts.

All this came to me as I was sitting with a friend on the patio of a restaurant in Scotts Valley, close to the coast, on the Fourth of July.

We live in a man-made world, according to sociologists, but according to believers, we live in a God-made world. I have lived in both those worlds. In Pakistan, where I am from, I would not dare say that I do not believe, for the religious authorities could and would behead me for such a “crime.”

I love the small-town feel in Scotts Valley — it’s a place where strangers approach you as if you have always known them. Tracy also is a small town, but it doesn’t have the same friendly feel.

I’ve learned that the cultural atmosphere of towns can change within 10 exits on the freeway. The Central Valley is known for being conservative, while the adjacent Bay Area is considered one of the most liberal places in the country.

The man who served us at the restaurant proceeded to pick some dog hair off my sleeve, while his friend joked with us that it was his excuse to touch a strange woman. We laughed.

I joked back, saying I make sure I have dog hair on my sleeve so strangers will touch my arm. They told me I was welcome to their town — I fit right in.

The conversation turned to the Fourth of July parade. People were gathering for fireworks, bringing chairs and ice coolers. The man serving us said something about being a right-wing conservative. My friend and I exchanged a look, as I’m known in Tracy for opposing everything right-wing.

I chided him, saying, “Oh no, a Bush fan?” He chided right back, “Obama?” I told him I had worked for the Obama campaign.

Democracy, he said, needs both a right wing and a left wing to stay afloat. I thought that was a good analogy, that in any environment, a balance of power requires freedom of expression of completely opposing opinions.

The U.S. Constitution allows people from all walks of life the right to individual expression and practice, without fear of

reprisal. And the Fourth of July, in essence, celebrates that right, that motto to seek life, liberty and happiness.

In my Utopia, in order to become president, a candidate does not have to justify that he or she goes to church. As an ardent believer, you don’t automatically fit in just because of that fact.

Why not choose to live with more than one individual at the same time without legal contract of marriage? Marriages of the mind, in which I would have two or three or more friends with whom I get along, could all live under the same roof as family without jealousy or the vice of possession. No one would have to change their name to symbolize that they “belonged” to another person or family. A man and a woman could have children together if they wished, without having to justify their children as “legitimate” or “illegitimate.” Men and women would live not as husband or wife but as friends and companions, free to love other people after the initial passion of a one-on-one relationship has evolved into communal responsibility and sharing.

I know, I know.

It was the Fourth of July, the air was tinted with the balm of redwoods from the nearby forests and I was in the company of relaxed intellectuals. My fantasies for a perfect world are just that — fantasies.

But I can dream, can’t I? After all, this is America, and I am an American woman.

• Samina Masood is a four-year resident of Tracy and is among a select group of local Town Crier columnists in the Tracy Press. She is a mother of two who has master’s degrees in both journalism and clinical psychology.
Comments
(19)
Comments-icon Post a Comment
shelly13
|
July 10, 2009
There is no one answer to it. But I think artifact is on to something.
artifact
|
July 10, 2009
The suppression of opinions, beliefs and values that are contrary to the powers that be is a hallmark of intolerance. You only need to see what is happening in Iran and China where the mere act of protest is a crime and you begin to appreciate what we have in this country, as imperfect as it may be.

The situation in Iran and China couldn't be any more different - one is ruled by a fundamentalist religious elite and the other by an atheist political party. Yet they are mirror images of each other in the way that they crush those that dare to oppose their ideas of truth and correct behavior. One is no better than the other and ultimately it's not a question of the merits of a specific religion or political party's ideology but more a question of their total lust for power and belief that they are the only ones who are able to define what is truth.
rcaptain
|
July 10, 2009
Mariamaria,

You reminded me of someone who once said, in democracy you have right to be stupid and your comment,

"Shame on Tracy Press for allowing such radical views in print. I am a proud Catholic woman raising two small kids in Tracy and go to church every Sunday. It is what keeps my home, my home town and our country safe and clean. We do not need people like Samina Masood to spread left wing godless agenda and corrupt our town morally! Shame on Tracy Press for allowing this kind of opinion to air," just proved that.

Fist of all, if Tracy Press can allow someone like you, who believes it's your religious value that is keeping this country safe, certainly, they have to allow Samina, who is much more coherent and intelligent, and has made a very compelling argument on the subject matter, to express her opinion, even when someone disagrees with her.

Second, who is to decide what is radical and what is idiotic rambling? To me, nothing you have written makes any sense.

Finally, those of you on right (although mostly wrong), who take every opportunity to invoke god's name and claim to have franchise license in morality, I have several names for you to keep in mind; Sanford, Ensign, Gingrich and Vitter. You should know that America is not buying your hypocrisy and bull-crap anymore and Obama’s election as the President has proven just that.

briandub
|
July 09, 2009
while I kinda agree with some of the below, its a bit too much conspiracy for me. Sure this country is based on capitalist economy and for the most that is a good thing. Power is a dangerous device whether its the church, the goverment, the people or businesses. The key is to have a balance. Have the freedom to follow your faith, but not the power to impose your faith on others. For those who follow what they believe to be the word of god, they too should keep an open mind and understand that those words have been twisted to justify the causes the followers want fullfilled.Good bad or otherwise for centuries.
kinaam66
|
July 09, 2009
I have been following this editorial since it was published and am amazed at the ignorance of people like Maria who claim to be Jesus lovers and yet spew so much hate. In all the comments I must commend Pablomehan for very accurately pointing out that this country is all about power, greed and the dollar, and nothing could be more godless than the corporations who run this country, namely, money laundering institutions such as the IMF, terrorist inciting institutions such as the CIA, the capitalist mafia which ignites war to keep it's hold on the economy, the subserviant government who kisses ass of the Saudi terrorists for oil, need I go on? America is not based on its beautifully worded principals of liberty and pursuit of happiness and religious freedom. It is based on avarice, power, greed, and twisting the arm of the masses to keep the rich richer and the middle class grinding endlessly to keep a machine based on human exploitation oiled, so that we keep bullying other countries, keep snatching that which does not belong to us, keep our children uneducated and drugged, our seniors dying and our economy catering to less than five percent of the billionairs who own this country while the rest of us prisoners slog away trying to make ends meet, harbouring the absent American dream which exists only on television.
mariamaria
|
July 09, 2009
Those who hate and fight are not religious people like us but communists and socialists like these Obama followers. America would be safer without these types, and no it is not meant for terrorists and Muslims to come here and call it their home, it is meant for Jesus lovers who must fight against these evil doers.
PabloMeehan
|
July 09, 2009
What some clearly forget is that we are all sons of Abraham if we are to believe the books that have been handed down over the centuries by our forefathers. Throughout those centuries avarice and power seemed to have appeared numerous times under the guise of religion.

If Christ were here would he not cast out the money changers?

Would he really allow the Vatican to exist as a world bank?

Would Moses not tell israel to set the Palestinians free?

Unfortunately in this world, the golden rule applies-HE WHO HAS THE GOLD MAKES ALL THE RULES.

briandub
|
July 09, 2009
I really enjoyed this editorial. I too have felt for a while that man's creation of religion designed to somehow give society structure has somehow only allowed people to hate/fight and kill each other over yet one more difference.

anonymous
|
July 09, 2009
I really enjoyed this editorial. I too have felt for a while that man's creation of religion designed to somehow give society structure has somehow only allowed people to hate/fight and kill each other over yet one more difference.

anonymous
|
July 09, 2009
If society encourages tolerance of all religions, atheism too, for those who do not believe, ought to be encouraged. Yet, in the so called freedom of America, no one who is an atheist can run for public office. Hard to find other minorities such as Muslims and Jews or Sikhs or Hindus as Congressman etc. So is America a Christian country or not? When we are forced by law to say 'one nation under God,' whose God are we referring to? Jesus, Vishnu, Allah, or Darwin?
sleepy2
|
July 09, 2009
Sir Thomas More coined Utopia in the title of his 1516 book. In it "The society encourages tolerance of all religions. " (Wiki)

So I don't see a Utopia without religion...
kl vosburg
|
July 09, 2009
The parlance of America being a Utopia is a far cry from what it's history suggests. Global diversities by it's very nature is a tribute against the mundane and utter redundancy of mono-hedgemon LLC. The problem (as many of you have already pointed out) religion becomes curiously subjective. It seems the deeper into it's breath and width the more anti-social one becomes. Let us not forget there are over 3 million within our armed services which allow those to partake in such a fantasy. While Scott's Valley may be real, a Utopia is merely a fictional account of a place which only exsists within the mind. And I think the guy pulling "dog hair from her sweater" may have actually slipped LSD into her Mocha Frappachino. -Don't forget to leave a tip, people in utopia's have too survive too.
kinaam66
|
July 08, 2009
Religion has NOT fostered brotherhood or moral values. It has just scared people into following delusional regimens. How can anyone with common sense actually believe in Noah's arc? Give me a break. Do you not see how much hatred religion has spread, how much division between man it has led to? If according to those who believe in God, there is one God, then all are his children. So why the divides? I don't feel that Christian love. Besides, America is not a Christian country, it is a secular country, where all, regardless, are free to live and preach or not preach. People like Maria pose a threat to intellectual growth. Our kids are stuffed with nonsense about 'one nation under God' to appease Catholic majorities, no one says one nation under 'Allah,' or one nation under 'Vishnu....' Get over it already, and stop stuffing delusions down the throats of those who are intelligent and delusion free!
anonymous
|
July 08, 2009
At the same time religions have taught us brotherhood, values, morals and social norms, without religion we would have anarchy, and moral chaos, and a valueless society in each was the master of his own whims and we could give our children no moral guide lines. What Samina proposes is just that, a world devoid of God, devoid of holy matrimony, children born of illicit relations, men and women living together in adultry. Is that the free world we want in America? As a devout Catholic I say,"never."
artifact
|
July 08, 2009
It's an unfortunate historical fact that religious differences have spawned many wars and cultural conflicts between the world's leaidng religions.

Samina's perspective is formed from her close and personal experience with religious intolerance of other people's beliefs and ideals. Isn't that what the American constitution was meant to protect?
mariamaria
|
July 08, 2009
There is no harm in sending our kids to church, or making sure they pray in school, it makes better people out of them. Those who think saying a prayer is against what America is are wrong. America is largely Christian and we have a right to make sure the work of our Lord

God Jesus is not lost due to these left wing radicals.
kinaam66
|
July 08, 2009
It's time someone came up to oppose the Catholic agenda running small towns like Tracy. What is next? Our kids being told they can't go to school unless they belong to a catholic church? This country was based on the separation of church and state. Let's keep it that way.
mariamaria
|
July 08, 2009
Shame on Tracy Press for allowing such radical views in print. I am a proud Catholic woman raising two small kids in Tracy and go to church every Sunday. It is what keeps my home, my home town and our country safe and clean. We do not need people like Samina Masood to spread left wing godless agenda and corrupt our town morally! Shame on Tracy Press for allowing this kind of opinion to air.
ronniedes
|
July 08, 2009
Brava! and thanks for putting into words something that I have always felt. Down with the artificial constructs that divide us and get in our way!


We encourage readers to share online comments in this forum, but please keep them respectful and constructive. This is not a space for personal attacks, libelous statements, profanity or racist slurs. Comments that stray from the topic of the story or are found to contain abusive language are subject to removal at the Press’ discretion, and the writer responsible will be subject to being blocked from making further comments and have their past comments deleted. Readers may report inappropriate comments by e-mailing the editor at tpnews@tracypress.com.