Conservationists fight the power lines
by Jennifer Wadsworth/ TP staff
May 05, 2009 | 938 views | 5 5 comments | 13 13 recommendations | email to a friend | print
A new set of power transmission lines through the Central Valley has some conservation groups worried for the safety and well-being of the state s wildlife.   Courtesy photo
A new set of power transmission lines through the Central Valley has some conservation groups worried for the safety and well-being of the state's wildlife. Courtesy photo
slideshow
Some conservationists worry that a proposed network of power lines that would stretch from Mt. Lassen and through the Central Valley could endanger wetlands and waterfowl.

Called the Transmission Agency of Northern California Transmission Project, the massive 600-mile network of power lines would connect dozens of utility plants throughout Northern California. The wires would branch off a few miles north of Tracy — westward to Livermore toward San Jose and east toward Modesto.

The proposed project would help ease congestion of California’s power grid much like widening a freeway would speed up traffic, said an agency spokeswoman. Less electrical “traffic,” she said, prevents power failures.

One of the proposed substations would sit just west of Mountain House, connected by wires that would extend across dozens of miles of privately owned Delta island wetlands just north of Tracy.

If built, the wires would cross too much restored wetland and migratory bird paths, say environmental groups Ducks Unlimited and the California Waterfowl Association. The power lines would cut through the Sutter National Wildlife Refuge, Stones Lake National Wildlife refuge and Butte Sink in Sacramento County and Yolo wildlife area. They would also stretch through lots of private, but federally protected wetlands.

Raptors, swans, geese and other large birds could run right into the wires, clip a wing and drop to the ground, said Rudy Rosen of Ducks Unlimited.

“Especially if it’s a foggy day, which you see a lot of in the valley,” he said. “If they’re not killed outright, usually predators will get them after they fall to the ground.

“Sometimes, you’ll see dead birds littering the ground beneath these power poles.”

Transmission Agency officials say they welcome the criticism and will include the feedback in the draft environmental impact review, which should be published sometime within the year. The public comment period ends May 31. If all goes as planned, construction would begin in 2014 at the earliest.

Rosen said he would rather see the wires follow the same paths as some existing utility networks, instead of winding through large swaths of untouched land. Otherwise, he said the proposed routes would mar 250,000 acres of wetlands — a fraction of what’s left from what used to be 5 million acres of undeveloped habitat for Northern California’s water birds.

Many private owners have restored wetland on their property that they placed on federal or state protective status, Rosen said. As planned, the power lines would span many of those easements.

“We’re talking about some of the most valuable wetlands in the state that this project would threaten,” Rosen said. “And for private property owners, it could even devalue their land.”

Rosen’s organization is encouraging people to write letters to the Transmission Agency — which represents 15 public utilities — to demand that officials revise the plan to more carefully consider its effects on wildlife.

About 60 percent of the Pacific Flyway’s waterfowl, and 20 percent of those in all of North America, winter or migrate through the Central Valley, according to Rosen.

He said he’s not opposed to the project itself, just the way it’s mapped out because he believes it could degrade public lands.

More than 1,000 people, including environmentalists, landowners and elected public officials, have commented on the proposed project since the comment period opened a couple of months ago, according to the Transmission Agency.
comments (5)
« LAM75 wrote on Thursday, May 07 at 01:25 PM »
Good Job, Amy! Wonderful staff and coffee from my buds at Baristas! I would really hate to see a maze of electrical wires out where I live and in the beauty of nature most highly ignore. Nature also gives the people who live on or near the wetlands money as well. Farming is popular there and it would be a hassle to have wires around. They do break as well. They will have to be repaired once placed.

Look at auto mechanics. When you buy a car, is it in perfect shape for your whole lifetime? No it isn't. That is why there are mechanics/auto repairmen. I am sure we will hear a lot more from people when they are a step away from placing the power lines here.
« ConcernedNeighbor wrote on Thursday, May 07 at 10:19 AM »
You got that right Lori!

I sure hope the lack of comments from Tracy residents does not mean they are "Okay" with this plan???

I for one, supported Holly Sports Park and Wetlands at Holly Site, and this rather puts monkey wrench in the plans???

""""One of the proposed substations would sit just west of Mountain House, connected by wires that would extend across dozens of miles of privately owned Delta island wetlands just north of Tracy."""" from this article for lack of quote icons.

Where are the smily faces, I miss those emoticons!

Well Lori, I had my hair done twice at Tangles when I lived in Tracy, great staff!! Good coffee next door, and post office just ahead.

I sure hope this proposal won't hurt the wetlands plans but then I would not visit if I saw huge cumbersome imposing power lines, attractive, I think not!! Now, who wants to buy a house around it???

Hope TracyRealNews, Francis Hineman/Skip will inform us more here?? Seems to know the inner workings of Tracy well?

Have a great day, go easy on Lori, Mike! (Kidding, Mike!) You do have a great staff!

« LAM75 wrote on Wednesday, May 06 at 03:07 PM »
I just got home from working my fingers to the bone at Tangles (j/k Mike, kinda) and Amy I am glad you commented. I need to get more people who live where I live and more further in the wetlands to protest this. Sure the electrical people are thinking green: Dollar bills and not vegetables, hay, and even trees.

No kidding. The value of the property here will hit rock bottom, but do the power people care? It doesn't look that way too me. They probably opened a new bank account? They say it is good for the public. I am part of the public people, and it is NOT good!

Fly a kite in an electrical wire. Play baseball without hitting a wire. Why not golfballs? Cropdusters fly as close as they can to the freeways (right CHP?) but are trained and do not hit vehicles. Now, they have to watch out for power lines.
« ConcernedNeighbor wrote on Wednesday, May 06 at 09:34 AM »
LAM, your concerns are shared by many who are aware of the dangers of living close and under and around the power lines. I'd stay away from them, myself.

Will this affect the "WetLands" plan at Holly?

I sure hope they aren't going to make the landscape UGLY with their imposing power lines. Power companies are not so sentiment in how they get increase in powers... shame on them for not incorporating the environmental and health standard with their plans. Just for the money and it isn't greener hills!

Why on fertile lands??? Engineers are smart enough to build great things on undesirable land. No?

Glad to see you still commenting here, Lori.

-amy/Observer

« LAM75 wrote on Wednesday, May 06 at 08:33 AM »
If they worry about birds, they better start worrying about humans as well! This plan my family has known about for a weeks and the public is not really informed that other things are indanger. These planned power lines will practically go right over my head and that means pure safety, right? Think again. Not only this, the farm land in this spacious is in danger as well. Cows going around, tractors going on fields, crop dusters, and then you throw in high voltage power lines? AHHHH!!!

Once it is built, it is perfect and never needs to be fixed or repaired. Oh sure, folks. I suggest if you do not care about the birds, take a look at the humans and farmland in danger. Think about your veggies and meat if necessary.


We encourage your online comments in this public forum, but please keep them respectful and constructive. This is not a forum for personal attacks, libelous statements, profanity or racist slurs. Readers may report such inappropriate comments by e-mailing the editor at tpnews@tracypress.com.