Political strategists will tell you that the key to winning is the ability to “control the message.” This seems to be the strategy adopted by Rep. Jerry McNerney, D-Pleasanton.
Politics today is not for the timid. People recently have gathered to let their representatives hear how they feel. Many times, these are angry displays, as voters feel as if their representatives are not acting in their best interests.
A recent video of Rep. Eric Massa, D-N.Y., is fuel for this fire. In this video, he publicly describes his constituents as “right-wingers” and that he will vote against the will of his district on the health care bill.
That is true arrogance. Indeed, the entire legislative branch seems to act above the people, telling them what is good for them despite what they feel. Reps. McNerney and Rep. Dennis Cardoza, D-Merced, have held zero public town hall meetings to discuss health care. McNerney has had “telephone town halls” — frustrated voters have given their opinions about these staged events.
Do McNerney, Cardoza and others who have opted for this “strategy” feel this is working?
I challenge McNerney to hold a real town hall with real voters, real concerns and real questions. Is he up to the challenge? Isn’t this part of his job? Or does he feel that we voters really don’t understand the wonderful benefits that his party’s leaders have proposed?
« HeyYogiii wrote on Thursday, Aug 27 at 01:28 PM »
Heck, I'm surprised he doesn't just call the hospitals on anonther "phoney" conference call? Didn't he say that was his 'preferred method' of communicating with people?
« HeyYogiii wrote on Thursday, Aug 27 at 01:22 PM »
Aren't those hospital visits just for show? Why not visit a forum where he can talk to the voters openly instead of photo ops?
« anonymous wrote on Thursday, Aug 27 at 09:44 AM »
I think Jerry McNerney so far has been making good use of both his time and our tax dollars by visiting hospitals, talking to doctors and staffs about their concerns. He is getting as much information as he can to make the best decisions regarding health care reform. Right now town halls are full of yelling and screaming the same talking points. People can call or e-mail his office and voice their concerns. I have and he responds. Why waste his time and ours shouting each other down.
« BargainingChip wrote on Wednesday, Aug 26 at 08:46 PM »
Interesting to watch this video. People went and didn't carry nazi signs.
But, Jerry, I wonder why these nice, concerned people can't get a meeting, per the above letter?
We can't even take the midday train to the doctors office in Pleasanton now because their ain't enough jobs to support transportation cost which is subsidized by gov."
So much fer tryin ta be green.
Cash4Klunkers? Thought it was ta stimulate th American Automobile Industry but as fer as I can tell Toyota, Honda and Ford, in that order, were the only one's ta benefit. An when ya consider th most modern automobile assembly plant resides in Mexico today I don't think much of that money will make it back inta th hands of th folk that foot th bill, namely th American Taxpayer.
Then ya got th Senator from NY that says he's gonna vote th way he wants regardless of th way his constituants that elected him want him ta vote. Ain't that a kick in th pants?
Yet ya don't hear much about it an I'm willin ta bet this bozo gets re-elected when th time comes.
Somebody should ask Jerry McNerney to focus on jobs and the promises like removin the troops and energy. What buying a foreign car with government Cash4Klunkers don't qualify as energy jobs, Jerry?
We can't even take the midday train to the doctors office in Pleasanton now because their ain't enough jobs to support transportation cost which is subsidized by gov.
But we can afford to pay foriegn car companies for their cars and give our own unymployed welfare healthcare.
Why a town hall meetin? He's just gonna tell ya what ya want ta hear an do what he thinks is best anyway. Save yer time, an next election vote fer th person that ain't th incumbant or don't vote at all. Or if ya really must vote, which ya should cause it's yer only voice, do a write-in. At least that sends th message to th other guy that ain't th incumbant that ya don't like his politics either.
BTW, I have it on personal knowledge ole Jerry is in favor of Nuclear energy an is against openin up our oil reserves even though it would wean us from th estimated 500 Billion dollars a year we give ta those people who then take the money an use it against th US.
An before ya attack th number, that information an number came from th lips of Congressman Jerry McNerney.
Ya might also ask his position on all these here wind machines that kill th eagles an make so much noise they bother th cows walkin around up thair in the dead of night.
« BargainingChip wrote on Wednesday, Aug 26 at 10:39 AM »
Good letter. Did anyone notice the operator in what was called a "phoney" confernece call said, 'hurry up', to the callers during Jerry's conference?
Why didn't Jerry McNerney ask her to stop saying that? How did she SELECT callers? I don't trust a conference call like that. Should be OPEN meeting too.
And I think this letter is right on. Kudos to the letter writer!
We encourage your online comments in this public forum, but please keep them respectful and constructive. This is not a forum for personal attacks, libelous statements, profanity or racist slurs. Readers may report such inappropriate comments by e-mailing the editor at tpnews@tracypress.com.
Insurance companies, Hospitals, Pharmacetucals all have BIG a stake at the financial table.
The American people SHOULD have been invited to Jerry's financial banquet earlier on.
Phoney? Why or why not, Jerry?
Personally, I didn't care for the "PHONEY" meeting, Jerry.
I think that only benefited the FEW?
Oh, I see it also got an article in the TP.
Thanks to DH for this letter!!!
But, Jerry, I wonder why these nice, concerned people can't get a meeting, per the above letter?
Scratchin' my head.
We can't even take the midday train to the doctors office in Pleasanton now because their ain't enough jobs to support transportation cost which is subsidized by gov."
So much fer tryin ta be green.
Cash4Klunkers? Thought it was ta stimulate th American Automobile Industry but as fer as I can tell Toyota, Honda and Ford, in that order, were the only one's ta benefit. An when ya consider th most modern automobile assembly plant resides in Mexico today I don't think much of that money will make it back inta th hands of th folk that foot th bill, namely th American Taxpayer.
Then ya got th Senator from NY that says he's gonna vote th way he wants regardless of th way his constituants that elected him want him ta vote. Ain't that a kick in th pants?
Yet ya don't hear much about it an I'm willin ta bet this bozo gets re-elected when th time comes.
We can't even take the midday train to the doctors office in Pleasanton now because their ain't enough jobs to support transportation cost which is subsidized by gov.
But we can afford to pay foriegn car companies for their cars and give our own unymployed welfare healthcare.
I love this country.
BTW, I have it on personal knowledge ole Jerry is in favor of Nuclear energy an is against openin up our oil reserves even though it would wean us from th estimated 500 Billion dollars a year we give ta those people who then take the money an use it against th US.
An before ya attack th number, that information an number came from th lips of Congressman Jerry McNerney.
Ya might also ask his position on all these here wind machines that kill th eagles an make so much noise they bother th cows walkin around up thair in the dead of night.
Why didn't Jerry McNerney ask her to stop saying that? How did she SELECT callers? I don't trust a conference call like that. Should be OPEN meeting too.
And I think this letter is right on. Kudos to the letter writer!