Second Thoughts: The right call for the war memorial
by Jon Mendelson / Tracy Press
Oct 14, 2011 | 3895 views | 4 4 comments | 36 36 recommendations | email to a friend | print
After a vigorous public discussion Tuesday, the Tracy War Memorial Association unanimously affirmed its May decision to include the name of Staff Sgt. David P. Senft on the list of hometown war casualties on the Tracy War Memorial.

But it wasn’t an easy row to hoe.

The meeting turned emotional at times, with nearly 50 people taking turns discussing why or why not — mostly why — Senft’s name should be graven on the black granite monument near Tracy City Hall.

The normally sleepy association gathering was swelled partly by a reaction to last week’s column, which revealed that at least a few members of the Tracy community didn’t agree with the decision to have Senft on the memorial because he committed suicide while stationed in Afghanistan.

A correction from that column, before we go further. Julie and Scott Conover, who did not agree with the War Memorial Association’s decision to include Senft’s name, did not formally petition to keep his name off the monument, as my column said.

They merely inquired as to how the decision was made and what the standards were for inclusion on the memorial and wanted to contribute their opinion.

My apologies for the error.

Now, back to the story.

On Tuesday, with the Conovers present, voices broke and some tempers flared during a meeting president John Treantos called the best-attended in association history.

Scott Conover, a blue star and gold star parent, took pains to state his opinion while acknowledging Senft’s service and the terrible loss endured by his family — Senft’s father and stepfather were also in attendance.

“We’re very, very sorry,” Conover said, his voice heavy with emotion. “I hate to say it here tonight, but that’s how we feel. We’re very, very sorry for the loss of your son.”

Mike Cotrell agreed.

“He chose to take his life, and I don’t agree with that,” Cotrell said, adding that suicide was not an honorable death.

But that opinion was squarely in the minority, as a quick scan of my inbox this week predicted.

In six years at the Press, and more than five years of writing Second Thoughts, nothing I’ve typed has generated as many e-mails and signed letters as last week’s column. And every single written correspondence I received was in favor of engraving Senft’s name on the war memorial.

I personally agree that adding the staff sergeant is the right thing to do, and the Press will be there on Veterans Day when his name is unveiled.

However, I didn’t agree with some of the tone of the Tuesday night meeting.

I acknowledge what an emotional issue suicide can be. More than one military veteran stood up and related how they had seen others despair and succumb, or told how close they’d been to turning a gun on themselves. And there was no shame in the sharing.

It was deeply powerful stuff, which should secure beyond a doubt Senft’s place on this community’s war memorial.

But too much of the criticism leveled at those who don’t share that view turned personal. It’s not fair to vilify those who see things otherwise — it takes courage to stand up and defend what you believe, especially when it’s unpopular. And I think this was an important conversation for our city to have.

In the end, there are no winners or villains here — just members of the same community struggling to deal with the scars of war.

This is a time to accept those differences and move on together, with full support for one another. In front of the war memorial Nov. 11 might be a good time and place to start.

• Second Thoughts is an opinion column by editor Jon Mendelson. To share your thoughts, e-mail him at
Comments-icon Post a Comment
October 16, 2011

Warfighter Boone Cutler is an author and Veterans' Rights leader that has become the first nationally recognized on-air personality who is also a Warfighter from the current war. 'Tipping Point with Boone Cutler' airs Saturday morning on Fox News Radio.


Boone approached Fox News Radio 99.1 FM Talk with the concept of a new show that focuses on national and international events based on the Warfighter's perspective. Boone's raw Paratrooper, no-holds-barred style has become a hit over the air waves and online with 'Soccer Moms' and his fellow Warfighters that are still deployed in combat zones worldwide.

Personal Information

Very dedicated Warfighters bring an end to the alarming Warfighter Suicide and Homeless rate.

Contact Ranger Karl Monger with

October 16, 2011
That's why they call it an "Editorial". It's an opinion stated by the Editors.
October 15, 2011
Good article. Glad ya corrected yerself when ya misstated th facts in yer original article.

I use ta thank suicide was th cowards way out but have grown ta understand that suicide is just another mental disease. It's sad that many don't thank about it. We take no umbrage when people get killed in active combat or even as innocent bystanders. We don't complain when many die of diseases they have no control over. Then why do we take umbrage when a person's mental condition has degraded ta th point where that person takes his own life?

Not wishin ta tarnish this man's memory or detract from th seriousness of his death, if he had, in his state of mind, killed a bunch of innocent people, was captured an awaitin trial wouldn't one defense be diminished mental capacity, meaning that he was mentally ill at th time an shouldn't be held accountable for th crime? So, if I understand it correctly many are willing, as a society under our system of justice, ta overlook carnage he might have caused innocents an get him th help he needed. But when he took his own life, show no compassion an strip him of the honorable service that regrettably caused his mental problems in th first place.

We encourage readers to share online comments in this forum, but please keep them respectful and constructive. This is not a space for personal attacks, libelous statements, profanity or racist slurs. Comments that stray from the topic of the story or are found to contain abusive language are subject to removal at the Press’ discretion, and the writer responsible will be subject to being blocked from making further comments and have their past comments deleted. Readers may report inappropriate comments by e-mailing the editor at