Second Thoughts: County hospital feels the hurt of the uninsured
by Jon Mendelson
Oct 10, 2009 | 726 views | 23 | 2 | |
Swerving to avoid being smashed by a big rig, a small car careens through the Interstate 5 median into oncoming rush-hour traffic.
Wildly spinning into the fast lane, the foreign compact crumples when it collides with an oncoming SUV and is sent screeching back onto the median.
Inside the twisted mass of metal is a young woman on her way to her job as a teacher and tutor. She’s bruised, battered and has a broken neck.
Paramedics soon rush to the northern reaches of the county, extract the young woman who’s unable to move, and sprint her away to San Joaquin General Hospital. There, she’s stabilized and observed for signs of lingering brain trauma before her release.
She is sore, stiff and wearing a neck brace, but alive and walking. She is also the reason the county hospital was $15.8 million in the red for 2008-09.
OK, so this one woman — a friend of mine whose name I won’t reveal at her request, but whose story is true — isn’t solely to blame. But stories like hers add up to a significant financial burden for the hospital.
This woman did not have medical insurance. Like so many Americans, she had a job that kind of paid the bills but did not provide health care coverage, and it didn’t pay enough so that she could buy insurance on the open market.
So when the medics asked her where the ambulance should take her, suggesting nearby Lodi Memorial Hospital, she said, “No. Take me to county. I don’t have insurance — it’s cheaper.”
Having just escaped death or paralysis by the sheerest of margins but by no means out of danger, she made a choice that could affect her life because of insurance and expense.
Incredible, but not uncommon. The statistics bear it out.
According to a report submitted in September to the county board of supervisors, San Joaquin General provides care to 62 percent of the county’s indigent and self-pay patients — read: the uninsured.
The hospital has a mandate to give emergency care even to those who can’t afford it. But that creates a problem in how to cover those services.
According to the county report, funding to cover care for that “indigent” population declined by $2.8 million in 2008-09, and another $2.6 million hit is expected this year. No wonder it’s been seven years since San Joaquin General “had sufficient revenue to cover expenses.”
Providing care to the uninsured isn’t the county hospital’s only financial problem — maintaining a residency program for doctors and a low volume of privately insured and Medicare patients, among others, also qualify — but it’s a big one. Caring for the uninsured digs a deeper hole than the outfit’s profitable operations can fill.
Though the money situation has improved significantly since the 2006-07 fiscal year, it’s still dire enough that shuttering the hospital is actually an option.
Expect every possibility to be exhausted before that, however, because the hospital is a crucial resource to the people who live here. If San Joaquin General closed tomorrow, the other hospitals in the region couldn’t handle the volume of patients.
On the other hand, leaving things the way they are isn’t an option, either.
Unfortunately, there aren’t any simple solutions within the current system. As with all things health care-related, the underlying problems and possible solutions are complex beyond the average armchair pundit’s wildest imagination. The more I learn about health care, the more I realize I don’t know.
But it’s at least clear that caring for the uninsured is an untenable unfunded mandate for the county hospital. And something serious must be done to change that if our hospital — or any hospital in the country, for that matter — is going to keep its doors open.
Short of that sweeping change, officials in San Joaquin County are on a desperate search for ways to keep the county hospital affordable and available to the people who live here.
Let’s hope — by hook or by crook — that they do.
Because my friend is walking today at least in part because of San Joaquin General. And that type of care should always be available to those who need it — whether they can pay for it or not.
• Share your thoughts with columnist and associate editor Jon Mendelson at jmendelson@tracypress.com. Or for more Second Thoughts, visit his blog.
You didn't get it right. At the Central/TracyBlvd Station they can park the fire truck inside the garage. I'd guess you don't even have a garage that big, but that'd be your business. Personally, i wouldn't want to clean a garage that big. And Fire Fighters have had living space at fire stations ever since ol Ben Franklin invented the water bucket on wheels. You'll get it later. Anyway, if someone ever bought that Fire Station (on Tracy/Central) they better bring their own motor home because that 'house' comes complete with a RV storage room in the oversized GARAGE.
More importantly. The fire station at Mountain House looks more like OUR fire station at Eleventh St. The new one beside Pombo's Real Estate office. Beside Safeway.
« TomBenigno wrote on Friday, Oct 16 at 06:07 PM »
Chilionastick:
Can't you take a joke? Years ago that how they did things, if you go to Central and Tracy Blvd you actually see the fire house was a house.
When I was in the military we lived on a O-11 fire truck, on the flight line.
With all due respect the MH Fire Station is not a 'foreclosed home' as you imagined, but dont take my word for it drive on over there and have a look for yourself. Anyway, if you're that concerned with sharing resources annex the special services district of Mountain House and be done with it. Think like a county supervisor, if that's even a real problem.
« TomBenigno wrote on Friday, Oct 16 at 09:51 AM »
Chilionastick:
You have too much time on your hands. Get a job.
MH has a fire truck in front of a house, plus 400 foreclosed homes. NO TAX MONEY.
See what it says there? Mountain House (MH) contracts with County Sherrif.
They already have a Fire Station in MH and the FD is consolidated with County too. So it makes sense. That way they get Emergency Rescue with FD while the County Ambulance makes their way to Mountain House.
What do your sneakers have to do with it? If you want I can post the information about Lathrop and Mountain House. As I said they pay the County for police (sherrifs) services. They made the information available online. I'll come back and post that later.
« TomBenigno wrote on Thursday, Oct 15 at 03:52 PM »
Concerned:
Just to add to the news process. Via Shaun Hannity. A lie will go half way around the world while the truth is putting on it's shoes. Let's get it right.
Lathrop also contracts their police with the county sherrif. Another thing. I watched the meeting on cable tv and never saw a mention of your moniker or the negotiations you are talking about. Run for County Sherrif. Then you'll know.
« TomBenigno wrote on Thursday, Oct 15 at 07:44 AM »
RHCP:
I don't think so. You had better go to some of these community workshop and city council meetings.
Actually Tom that's not true either. Mountain House contracts with the COUNTY for police and fire. Didn't you run for County Supervisor?
They already share our existing, outgrown, hospital (Sutter). And Sutter already factored in the need for 100 to 120 additional beds at Sutter Hospital. Check out Sutter in Modesto Tom. And Kaiser also helps validate.
When Federal healthcare reform kikcs in won't there be millions more Americans with insurance?
« TomBenigno wrote on Wednesday, Oct 14 at 08:45 AM »
Chili:
Wrong again. Sharing a hospital with MH would just add another cost to Tracy tax payers,we are now sharing police and fire with them.
Joining them will just add to the cost of our first responders. Mountain House has a tax base let them spend it as they see fit, on their own hospital.
That hospital wont be built till 2018. Even Kimball High School wasn't selected by local government. It was selected by State of California to serve both Tracy and Mountain House. But more importantly there's no better location. The Gateway Park has the most convenient freeway access. Think about eleventh St at Tracy Blvd and even down to mc Arthur. Sutter Hospital at 11th and Lammers will also serve Mountain House. So aside from a complaint about who owns the land we haven't presented any legitimate reasons to oppose a hospital in Tracy. You want jobs in Stockton because of a political opponent? Think about it someone owned the Ellis property did you oppose the swim center? There's no valid reason to oppose that either just because a land owner. If I missed the mark let us know.
There aren't legitimate environmental issues to file a frivolous lawsuit about?
« TomBenigno wrote on Tuesday, Oct 13 at 04:21 PM »
Chilionastick:
I don't like the Gateway location because Ornellas. has his hands all over the deal. He never helped me so that is that. I hope you enjoy your time here, in Tracy.
Try to reason and I'll listen. But the economy may be in the hands of Congress. Im not interested in Venezualian conspiracy theories. Remember, the article says everyone should have access. That's where we disagree, but to go a little further - that implicitly means Tracy needs Sutter's new hospital too. I dont see anything wrong with the Gateway location. I don't live in Stockton. I don't live in French Camp which isn't even our Congressional District. Remember, it will serve MH, and other districts too.
« TomBenigno wrote on Tuesday, Oct 13 at 12:27 PM »
Chili:
There is no reasoning with you, you have an agenda and you won't concede that the present economy is going in the tank.
The subject at hand was jobs for the people of the valley and you talk about some other issue that does not match the subject matter. That is typical NAZI tactic sir.
What's wrong is saying doctors will have to "relocate". I've had several doctors from Tracy. Every year you find them serving our comunity at Sutter Health Fair and other events. Modesto has Sutter too. They already expended Stockton's Hospital. Location, location, location. Who cares? This is Tracy not Spanis Park
« TomBenigno wrote on Monday, Oct 12 at 09:42 PM »
Chili:
You are dead wrong again, just wait and see waht happens.
I don't believe it for a minute. There are plenty of doctors living in Tracy. If you want you can get a referral. This way you don't have to commute from Tracy to Stockton. Get a second opinion locally.
You didn't get it right. At the Central/TracyBlvd Station they can park the fire truck inside the garage. I'd guess you don't even have a garage that big, but that'd be your business. Personally, i wouldn't want to clean a garage that big. And Fire Fighters have had living space at fire stations ever since ol Ben Franklin invented the water bucket on wheels. You'll get it later. Anyway, if someone ever bought that Fire Station (on Tracy/Central) they better bring their own motor home because that 'house' comes complete with a RV storage room in the oversized GARAGE.
More importantly. The fire station at Mountain House looks more like OUR fire station at Eleventh St. The new one beside Pombo's Real Estate office. Beside Safeway.
Can't you take a joke? Years ago that how they did things, if you go to Central and Tracy Blvd you actually see the fire house was a house.
When I was in the military we lived on a O-11 fire truck, on the flight line.
Later.
With all due respect the MH Fire Station is not a 'foreclosed home' as you imagined, but dont take my word for it drive on over there and have a look for yourself. Anyway, if you're that concerned with sharing resources annex the special services district of Mountain House and be done with it. Think like a county supervisor, if that's even a real problem.
You have too much time on your hands. Get a job.
MH has a fire truck in front of a house, plus 400 foreclosed homes. NO TAX MONEY.
See what it says there? Mountain House (MH) contracts with County Sherrif.
They already have a Fire Station in MH and the FD is consolidated with County too. So it makes sense. That way they get Emergency Rescue with FD while the County Ambulance makes their way to Mountain House.
Make sense now?
Just to add to the news process. Via Shaun Hannity. A lie will go half way around the world while the truth is putting on it's shoes. Let's get it right.
I don't think so. You had better go to some of these community workshop and city council meetings.
They already share our existing, outgrown, hospital (Sutter). And Sutter already factored in the need for 100 to 120 additional beds at Sutter Hospital. Check out Sutter in Modesto Tom. And Kaiser also helps validate.
When Federal healthcare reform kikcs in won't there be millions more Americans with insurance?
Problem solved, Tom.
Wrong again. Sharing a hospital with MH would just add another cost to Tracy tax payers,we are now sharing police and fire with them.
Joining them will just add to the cost of our first responders. Mountain House has a tax base let them spend it as they see fit, on their own hospital.
There aren't legitimate environmental issues to file a frivolous lawsuit about?
I don't like the Gateway location because Ornellas. has his hands all over the deal. He never helped me so that is that. I hope you enjoy your time here, in Tracy.
There is no reasoning with you, you have an agenda and you won't concede that the present economy is going in the tank.
The subject at hand was jobs for the people of the valley and you talk about some other issue that does not match the subject matter. That is typical NAZI tactic sir.
You are dead wrong again, just wait and see waht happens.