Her Voice: Land of opportunity not without its hellish trials
by Maya Masood/For the Tracy Press
Nov 28, 2009 | 996 views | 17 | 12 | |
People often talk about defining moments in their lives, moments in which they inquired deep within, moments of deep realization.
Life-changing moments like these can be very sweet, or unbearably bitter. Imagine wandering through life bearing a dead soul, drained of its liveliness. Imagine living in a dead, bitter moment — but not just for a moment, for years.
Sadness lingers in my heart. I had to leave my relatives and move to America.
Being socially accepted at school in the South was difficult, just for looking “different.” Yet I was a happy and vibrant little girl: confident, self-willed and the clown of the household.
I hated my parents for wanting me to move. They lost every bit of dignity, kissed up to people who were nothing short of rude and condescending. All we could do was keep our heads held low, say yes to people in “power,” get passage to a country that was promising. In my mind, the cons outweighed the pros.
Despite making new friends, a jolt had set in. I was unwelcome and different. The attacks of Sept. 11 happened. Our shock was seen as rudimentary compared to Caucasian despair. It was as if we were personally responsible, extensions of the terrorists.
A boy in my school, an army man’s son, said with teachers and students present that I should die. I told my mother, in my then 10-year-old brain, that he was going to kill me.
She called the principal’s secretary, ironically named Miss White. My mother was told that it was too small a matter for the principal.
My mother, passionate and feisty, called the local newspaper, which ran an article. The next day, the principal was at our door, flooding our living room with disingenuous apologies. I saw through the hypocrisy of the system. They cared only if their reputation depended on showing minimum regard to a “foreigner.”
The principal had no answer to my mother’s question. What if it had been a Muslim child threatening death to a white child?
I visited my grandparents, only to find the void furthered. My grandpa was in a wheelchair, my grandma bedridden and my home was no longer my home. My mother and I left our hearts behind. I saw through my mother’s façade, strong with bloodshot eyes. Her pain ran deep.
At the New York airport, we were picked on by customs officers, one who raised his voice, shouting at us for not filling out the arrival form correctly. I wanted to hit him.
Instead, we stood with our eyes lowered, afraid of deportation. After several hours and interviews, they let us re-enter.
I wanted no part of this country and its humiliation, but the humiliation only strengthened.
It was 4 a.m. and my father was away in another state for work. The door sounded like someone was breaking it down. My mother looked outside to see the front yard sprawling with policemen with guns. It was the INS and FBI. They had come to deport us, unless we produced further papers.
My mother was thinly clad. She asked if she could dress, but the agents shouted “No!” She had to let a dozen men in as she walked around semi-naked, fishing for legal documents. They ransacked the house, talking to her rudely. They confiscated our papers, told her not to leave the house — not even for groceries — without her passport, or she would be arrested. They left.
She collapsed to the floor crying, holding me and my brother on either side, rocking us and saying, “It’s going to be all right.”
Now, nearly 10 years later, we were granted green cards. I have a splendid boyfriend, graduated from high school, and am following my dreams.
I understand more as I become a woman why my mother wanted to leave Pakistan. I am grateful for all the misery she spared me in that country, but there is a huge teardrop lodged within me, like an eternal bubble. It won’t ever burst.
Choosing between hells is hardly a choice. Precious friends and the chance to carve out a life make it all worthwhile. Somewhere between my grandmother’s embrace and my mother’s sacrifice lies my chance at redemption.
I know I will one day be able to fully appreciate life.
• Maya Masood is a 2009 West High School graduate and attends Las Positas College as a full-time student. She has lived in Tracy for four years.
Davel66, needles- I was quite careful to not say "my" country. If you re-read my post I said to the writer "our" country. I purposely said that because I feel that because this country is all of ours regardless or race, religion or place or origin.
Some writers were so quick to pounce on my comments, why? Why is it that the original writers letter was somehow "brave" yet mine are considered "arrogant" or "ignorant?"
Like I said in my post, I have nothing against the writer, I did take issue with her comments about the country which provides so much. I do not believe that America is some kind of "hell." Am I arrogant to take issue with a portrayal of America as being some kind of hell?
Am I critical of some of the actions that our country does? Of course I am. I do however believe that I have a responsibility to give credit to the nation and its people for affording me the freedoms that I enjoy.
I was called arrogant or ignorant by my comments. Could I call the writer the same thing, would that have been okay? I chose not to.
I do stand my my post and I hope that the writer sees that despite the unfortunate circumstances and experience she had witnessed that she will see the blessings of living in a great nation.
I come from countries that were historically degraded and oppressed, yet I will choose to look forward and not look back at the unfortunate circumstances that surround my past. Thankfully despite some of America's shortcomings I enjoy many freedoms and i will try to change our weaknesses from within and with a positive approach.
I appreciate the struggle the young lady had to endure while growing up. I, too, struggled. I am an American born caucasian. Lots of children suffer injustice for various reasons. The original offender in her victimization are her parents. I understand why they wanted to leave Pakistan. Still, they took their children away from their home, country, culture, language, family and friends. They brought them to a country that was already at odds with Muslim countries. When the attacks on 9/11 occured the U.S. government had to take action against that kind of terrorism. It was no longer a choice to offer the American people the freedoms we once took for granted. Any time the government officials believe that a person has terrorist intent they are allowed, by law, to go into their home. That includes me. Anyone of us can be a victim of that sort of policing. Still, I would rather give up my right to privacy than to go to the funeral of one of my loved ones because of a terrorist act. I am proud to be an American. I am blessed to have been born here.
« anonymous wrote on Thursday, Dec 03 at 01:42 PM »
Let’s see Davel66 talks about profiling.
I bet 13 great Americans and their families at Fort Hood wishes someone did a little more profiling and a lot less P.C.
When this coward, piece of sh-- murdered these great Americans, What did the teleprompter man say? Let’s not jump to conclusions.
Months before a White police officer has a call involving a affirmative action black professor and the teleprompter man with out any facts said, Oh' the White police officer acted stupidly.
Great, and people say there is not a double standard.
Sure glad we didn’t have people like you around during World War II. If we did, I’m am sure we would be speaking a different langue’s today.
I agree with Davel, we need to accept that there are many thing America needs to learn to do different, and behaving high handedly with minorities is a real not imaginary issue, instead of condoning what is wrong, it is patriotic to speak up against it so we can improve. We are not perfect even if we are better than other countries. Money is a guiding principal in our country, even the poor are a minority who don't enjoy the same rights, let's call a spade a spade.
Washingtonpost.com CAIR "received 1,019 complaints from Muslims last year concerning discriminatory or violent actions, up from 602 the year before ..."
Maybe there WAS more discrimination against Muslims last year than in 2002. Or maybe Muslims are just filing complaints more often. CAIR's web site certainly makes it easy enough, and certainly encourages people to do so.
Are these numbers culled from reports solicited by CAIR's Web site? If so, why should I give them any more credence than any other self-selected sample?
Dr. Mohamed Nimer: Many of the incidents contained in CAIR's report, especially the most serious ones, have been verified by third parties. It's true that in some cases, like reports of harassment, there were not witnesses, but they offer credible data that can inform the public. This is why it is important to report them.
CAIR received more than 1,750 complaints, of which we believe 1019 cases had credible data.
Most Popular Foreign Policy Posts1.Institutional Support for Torture Undermines Government's Legitimacy
2.Immigration Raids Increase Pressure to Migrate
3.Modern Population Control Movement Motivated By Nativism
4.No Accountability When It Comes to Noncitizen Uighurs
5.CNN Parrots Pentagon on Prisoner Abuse Photos
..Most Popular Immigration PostsThis Week
This Month.1.Economy Works For U.S. Border Patrol
2.A Thanksgiving Marred By An Archaic Immigration System
3.Story of A Desperate Musician
4.Singing Forces Arpaio Out of ASU Forum
5.Holiday Travel Tips for Immigrants
Victory: Lou Dobbs Takes Voluntary Departure from CNN"Deport Us Now"Anti-Immigration Forces DwindlingWill Pelosi Cave to Anti-Immigrant Sentiments on HCR?Korean-American Student Shares More Than Secrets...Foreign Policy
Immigrants Serve Abroad While Fighting Deportation At Home
by Prerna Lal
category: Foreign Policy
Published November 11, 2009 @ 11:27AM PT
Pfc. Kham Xiong, was one of 11 children of Hmong refugees. He followed in the footsteps of a younger brother and his father, who fought Communists in Laos during the Vietnam War and fled with his family to Thailand, where Kham Xiong was born
Xiong was only 23 when he died in the gunfire at Fort Hood last week.
One bad apple does not represent all apples but it might be hard to gain that wisdom from mainstream media coverage around the Fort Hood tragedy, which gets no awards for racial or religious sensitivity. Today, as we honor our veterans and fallen soldiers, Muslims in the military fear a backlash in return of their service. It is crucial to lay rest to a cloud of xenophobia that threatens the safe existence of immigrants in the military, where they have served proudly since the Revolutionary War.
A newly released timely report from the Immigration Policy Center, Essential to the Fight: Immigrants in the Military, Eight Years After 9/11, highlights the critical role immigrants are playing in today's military. Non-citizens make up 5% of all troops in the U.S. military and since 9-11, over 150 immigrants have been killed while serving. The report notes that "without the contributions of immigrants, the military could not meet its recruiting goals and could not fill its need for foreign-language translators, interpreters and cultural experts."
Some notable statistics from the report:
•As of June 30, 2009, there were 114,601 foreign-born individuals serving in the armed forces, representing 7.91 percent of the 1.4 million military personnel on active duty.
•In Fiscal Year (FY) 2009 alone, 10,505 members of the military were naturalized. Naturalizations of immigrants in the military are at their highest during times of war."
Silent Victims: The Plight of Arab & Muslim Americans in Post 9/11 America
Aladdin Elaasar
Format ISBN Price
Paperback (6x9) 9781418410551 $ 18.75
.About the BookAbout the AuthorFree Preview." Whenever people face sadness and tragedy then complimenting something that comes out of it becomes harder. This book provides the nation with a rich detailed lived history, which did not begin with September 11, 2001. It is an excellent compilation of events, reports and lived experiences. This documented collection of story will give readers a new chance to fill in the gaps within a historical context that Arabs and Muslims Americans have lived in. In the wake of the events of 9/11, since the tears flooded our faces, we have been forced to recount the events that created the bias and hostility toward Muslims, Arabs, and Islam. This book is a must read for those who are willing to consider the possibility that Arab and Muslim Americans should not become the scapegoats for the world''s disharmony."
Dr. Sima Imam, Professor of Education at National Louis University, Illinois, and President of American Muslim Civil Rights.
The increasing public’s curiosity about the Arabs, Muslims and the Arab and Muslim Americans in the United States has been unprecedented. This book explains the phenomenon of stereotypes stigmatizing Arabs and Muslims, and how it has affected their lives, a phenomenon that demonized and dehumanized almost two billion people in this world."
By Abdus Sattar Ghazali, United Muslims of America http://www.umanet.org
- A Muslim bus passenger en route to Chicago is put off with his bags in Toledo after he told the driver he is from Iraq. (Detroit Free Press - June 12, 2007)
- Dearborn offices of two Muslim charities - Al-Mabarrat Charitable Organization and Goodwill Charitable Organization - are raided. (Detroit Free Press - July 24, 2007)
- A mosque in Rochester (New York) has been vandalized for the three times this year. (Associated Press - May 30)
These recent episodes symbolize the dilemma of American Muslims in the post-9/11 America. Six years after the terrorist attacks, American Muslims remain under siege with institutionalized profiling, discrimination, high profile trials, raid on Muslim charities and defaming of mainstream Muslim organizations. Muslim Americans have experienced a large volume of negative reprisals from sectors of the American public in the form of violent hate crimes, defamatory speech, attacks on hijab-wearing Muslim women and discrimination and harassment at work place. There is discrimination against non-citizen Muslims.
Did anyone note how arrogant Mike77 sounded when he told the author to be grateful to his country? Is this not mislead patriotism? If we were truly great we would be apologizing to the author not reprimanding her for being ungrateful, she went through hell as a child and has a right to call us on it, we made that hell possible by our tendencies at imperialism, which are not biting us in the rear.
I must say I am not surprised at some of the comments. We are a nation of ignorants, and we can't bear to hear the truth about ourselves unless it is flattering. We bully the world and want it to succumb to us. All this is changing, arrogance does not last, and others have a right to speak up against inhuamanity. It is inhuman to treat minorities as lesser beings, and we have done it for generations, from native Indians to Blacks to Muslims. We have a lot to be grateful for and proud of, namely a first Black President, but we need a lot of damage control given the Bush era masaccres, of which this child is but one example.
For the record, no where in the article did the author not express remorse that 9/11 happened. What was clear to me was that she felt when she tried to share in the American sorrow, she was made to feel like an outsider simply because she was Muslim and somehow lumped in the enemy category. Which is what readers are doing below. Shame on us.I think we as American owe young children who were victims of hate crimes an apololgy rather than feeling threatened.
Why are we so quick to be offended and go on the offensive if someone is brave enough to point out a bad experience they had at the hands of the system? America is not perfect. During the Bush era there were thousands of such incidents which destroyed innocent families even though they were innocent, simply because they were Muslim. It is documented. People were thrown in jails for no good reason and people's houses ransacked without due process. It is a nightmare for a child to witness this horror and I applaud this young lady for having the courage to speak her mind and share her experience.
Was your goal was to show the evil of America and how you are a victim and now I should feel bad? Were you trying to build bridges between your world and our American Life? Well you missed the point in my books.
Instead what I heard is that while misguided, the emotions of 9-11 are all somehow America's fault. Its the same thing all the time.
The fact remains we were attacked. Did you ever become so inspired to write to your native lands about their problems? Probably not, because your speech would most likely be suppressed.
You compare America and your native country to Hell?? Really, then why do you stay? Perhaps Canada is a better choice... Pop the tear and look at what you have, or just move along.
You stay because despite a few individuals who were mean to you, you have a good life here, certainly better than where you came from.
Try writing a more balanced letter with just an ounce of gratitude toward our country. That is a better start. I have nothing against you, I would just expect a slight shred of gratitude for the freedoms America affords you, that is a better starting place.
By the way, I have been pulled aside a number of times at the airport, it's a small price to pay so some idiot doesn't decide to hijack an airplane and run it into a building. Instead of complaining I'll just say thanks to the TSA, FBI, INS and all the other agencies that are doing their best.
Just Wondering, So you’re saying a DOZEN INS and FBI agents with guns at FOUR in the morning almost breaking down your door, just to check your papers?
Was there also Blackhawk helicopters circling around your home with search lights on?
Your Words “Choosing between hells is hardly a choice”. America is hell, Really,
I for one feel lucky and proud to live in America.
« needless wrote on Saturday, Nov 28 at 10:18 PM »
I was truly touched that a young woman in Tracy shared her story. I too came from migrant parents and know how it is to feel a void. For those who come to our new country, there is always emotional cost, especially leaving old parents and grandparents behind. It is indeed hard to leave and hard not to leave, given the condition of the countries we leave. It is hard to make a life during economic and political upheavle and even those born here work very hard to survive. But hard work pays off as it did in the case of the young author and her parents. We all need to gel as a nation and remember that not long ago we all came here from somewhere else and that therefore we are all equal and deserve respect and friendship.
« needless wrote on Saturday, Nov 28 at 10:14 PM »
We encourage your online comments in this public forum, but please keep them respectful and constructive. This is not a forum for personal attacks, libelous statements, profanity or racist slurs. Readers may report such inappropriate comments by e-mailing the editor at tpnews@tracypress.com.
Some writers were so quick to pounce on my comments, why? Why is it that the original writers letter was somehow "brave" yet mine are considered "arrogant" or "ignorant?"
Like I said in my post, I have nothing against the writer, I did take issue with her comments about the country which provides so much. I do not believe that America is some kind of "hell." Am I arrogant to take issue with a portrayal of America as being some kind of hell?
Am I critical of some of the actions that our country does? Of course I am. I do however believe that I have a responsibility to give credit to the nation and its people for affording me the freedoms that I enjoy.
I was called arrogant or ignorant by my comments. Could I call the writer the same thing, would that have been okay? I chose not to.
I do stand my my post and I hope that the writer sees that despite the unfortunate circumstances and experience she had witnessed that she will see the blessings of living in a great nation.
I come from countries that were historically degraded and oppressed, yet I will choose to look forward and not look back at the unfortunate circumstances that surround my past. Thankfully despite some of America's shortcomings I enjoy many freedoms and i will try to change our weaknesses from within and with a positive approach.
I bet 13 great Americans and their families at Fort Hood wishes someone did a little more profiling and a lot less P.C.
When this coward, piece of sh-- murdered these great Americans, What did the teleprompter man say? Let’s not jump to conclusions.
Months before a White police officer has a call involving a affirmative action black professor and the teleprompter man with out any facts said, Oh' the White police officer acted stupidly.
Great, and people say there is not a double standard.
Sure glad we didn’t have people like you around during World War II. If we did, I’m am sure we would be speaking a different langue’s today.
Maybe there WAS more discrimination against Muslims last year than in 2002. Or maybe Muslims are just filing complaints more often. CAIR's web site certainly makes it easy enough, and certainly encourages people to do so.
Are these numbers culled from reports solicited by CAIR's Web site? If so, why should I give them any more credence than any other self-selected sample?
Dr. Mohamed Nimer: Many of the incidents contained in CAIR's report, especially the most serious ones, have been verified by third parties. It's true that in some cases, like reports of harassment, there were not witnesses, but they offer credible data that can inform the public. This is why it is important to report them.
CAIR received more than 1,750 complaints, of which we believe 1019 cases had credible data.
Home » Blog Index
Most Popular Foreign Policy Posts1.Institutional Support for Torture Undermines Government's Legitimacy
2.Immigration Raids Increase Pressure to Migrate
3.Modern Population Control Movement Motivated By Nativism
4.No Accountability When It Comes to Noncitizen Uighurs
5.CNN Parrots Pentagon on Prisoner Abuse Photos
..Most Popular Immigration PostsThis Week
This Month.1.Economy Works For U.S. Border Patrol
2.A Thanksgiving Marred By An Archaic Immigration System
3.Story of A Desperate Musician
4.Singing Forces Arpaio Out of ASU Forum
5.Holiday Travel Tips for Immigrants
Victory: Lou Dobbs Takes Voluntary Departure from CNN"Deport Us Now"Anti-Immigration Forces DwindlingWill Pelosi Cave to Anti-Immigrant Sentiments on HCR?Korean-American Student Shares More Than Secrets...Foreign Policy
Immigrants Serve Abroad While Fighting Deportation At Home
by Prerna Lal
category: Foreign Policy
Published November 11, 2009 @ 11:27AM PT
Pfc. Kham Xiong, was one of 11 children of Hmong refugees. He followed in the footsteps of a younger brother and his father, who fought Communists in Laos during the Vietnam War and fled with his family to Thailand, where Kham Xiong was born
Xiong was only 23 when he died in the gunfire at Fort Hood last week.
One bad apple does not represent all apples but it might be hard to gain that wisdom from mainstream media coverage around the Fort Hood tragedy, which gets no awards for racial or religious sensitivity. Today, as we honor our veterans and fallen soldiers, Muslims in the military fear a backlash in return of their service. It is crucial to lay rest to a cloud of xenophobia that threatens the safe existence of immigrants in the military, where they have served proudly since the Revolutionary War.
A newly released timely report from the Immigration Policy Center, Essential to the Fight: Immigrants in the Military, Eight Years After 9/11, highlights the critical role immigrants are playing in today's military. Non-citizens make up 5% of all troops in the U.S. military and since 9-11, over 150 immigrants have been killed while serving. The report notes that "without the contributions of immigrants, the military could not meet its recruiting goals and could not fill its need for foreign-language translators, interpreters and cultural experts."
Some notable statistics from the report:
•As of June 30, 2009, there were 114,601 foreign-born individuals serving in the armed forces, representing 7.91 percent of the 1.4 million military personnel on active duty.
•In Fiscal Year (FY) 2009 alone, 10,505 members of the military were naturalized. Naturalizations of immigrants in the military are at their highest during times of war."
Aladdin Elaasar
Format ISBN Price
Paperback (6x9) 9781418410551 $ 18.75
.About the BookAbout the AuthorFree Preview." Whenever people face sadness and tragedy then complimenting something that comes out of it becomes harder. This book provides the nation with a rich detailed lived history, which did not begin with September 11, 2001. It is an excellent compilation of events, reports and lived experiences. This documented collection of story will give readers a new chance to fill in the gaps within a historical context that Arabs and Muslims Americans have lived in. In the wake of the events of 9/11, since the tears flooded our faces, we have been forced to recount the events that created the bias and hostility toward Muslims, Arabs, and Islam. This book is a must read for those who are willing to consider the possibility that Arab and Muslim Americans should not become the scapegoats for the world''s disharmony."
Dr. Sima Imam, Professor of Education at National Louis University, Illinois, and President of American Muslim Civil Rights.
The increasing public’s curiosity about the Arabs, Muslims and the Arab and Muslim Americans in the United States has been unprecedented. This book explains the phenomenon of stereotypes stigmatizing Arabs and Muslims, and how it has affected their lives, a phenomenon that demonized and dehumanized almost two billion people in this world."
By Abdus Sattar Ghazali, United Muslims of America http://www.umanet.org
- A Muslim bus passenger en route to Chicago is put off with his bags in Toledo after he told the driver he is from Iraq. (Detroit Free Press - June 12, 2007)
- Dearborn offices of two Muslim charities - Al-Mabarrat Charitable Organization and Goodwill Charitable Organization - are raided. (Detroit Free Press - July 24, 2007)
- A mosque in Rochester (New York) has been vandalized for the three times this year. (Associated Press - May 30)
These recent episodes symbolize the dilemma of American Muslims in the post-9/11 America. Six years after the terrorist attacks, American Muslims remain under siege with institutionalized profiling, discrimination, high profile trials, raid on Muslim charities and defaming of mainstream Muslim organizations. Muslim Americans have experienced a large volume of negative reprisals from sectors of the American public in the form of violent hate crimes, defamatory speech, attacks on hijab-wearing Muslim women and discrimination and harassment at work place. There is discrimination against non-citizen Muslims.
Instead what I heard is that while misguided, the emotions of 9-11 are all somehow America's fault. Its the same thing all the time.
The fact remains we were attacked. Did you ever become so inspired to write to your native lands about their problems? Probably not, because your speech would most likely be suppressed.
You compare America and your native country to Hell?? Really, then why do you stay? Perhaps Canada is a better choice... Pop the tear and look at what you have, or just move along.
You stay because despite a few individuals who were mean to you, you have a good life here, certainly better than where you came from.
Try writing a more balanced letter with just an ounce of gratitude toward our country. That is a better start. I have nothing against you, I would just expect a slight shred of gratitude for the freedoms America affords you, that is a better starting place.
By the way, I have been pulled aside a number of times at the airport, it's a small price to pay so some idiot doesn't decide to hijack an airplane and run it into a building. Instead of complaining I'll just say thanks to the TSA, FBI, INS and all the other agencies that are doing their best.
Was there also Blackhawk helicopters circling around your home with search lights on?
Your Words “Choosing between hells is hardly a choice”. America is hell, Really,
I for one feel lucky and proud to live in America.